Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

homestead - Re: [Homestead] was It's almost over, now wending to Amish response to aggression

homestead AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Homestead mailing list

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: bob ford <bobford79 AT yahoo.com>
  • To: homestead AT lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: Re: [Homestead] was It's almost over, now wending to Amish response to aggression
  • Date: Thu, 4 Dec 2008 15:48:47 -0800 (PST)

That was all very interesting Susan. I didn't know nuch of what you wrote.
'just a curiosity about the obvious. The groups are not large. How do they
keep new bloodlines?. Do people come from state to state or whatever to date
and marry?

--------------------------------------------------------------------


--- On Thu, 12/4/08, sjc <indexer AT fairpoint.net> wrote:

> From: sjc <indexer AT fairpoint.net>
> Subject: Re: [Homestead] was It's almost over, now wending to Amish
> response to aggression
> To: homestead AT lists.ibiblio.org
> Date: Thursday, December 4, 2008, 4:42 PM
> EarthNSky wrote:
> >
> > I meant that our species has a built in capability
> for aggression,
> > for violence, and that often leads to warring.
> >
> With that statement I can totally agree.
>
> > I would venture to guess that even among a peaceful
> group like the Amish
> > that young men might resort to a fistfight over a
> young lady. The
> > behavior of those during Rumschpringe is often
> different than their
> > behavior at home.
> >
> >
> Possibly. I'm sure it's happened. Not sure about
> all these
> 'documentaries' I hear about (maybe I need to start
> watching TV?) But
> in any case, the past 30 years or so, since drugs have been
> ubiquitous,
> have forever changed many, especially young, populations.
> I've heard
> some real horror stories, and since each group (almost no
> hierarchy in
> Anabaptist groups, usually 2 preachers, a 'new' and
> a 'main' preacher,
> all chosen by lot, and 3 churches to a bishop, who is also
> 'main'
> preacher for one of the 3 churches) is it's own
> 'boss' there are lots of
> usus\ally small variances in the tolerance levels from
> one group to
> another. In the part of the country where I grew up, once
> you joined
> church, no more rumschpringge, period, because at the least
> there were
> usually musical instruments, or in that day I grew up,
> battery
> recordplayers.
>
> In some areas alcohol was tolerated, but usage usually
> moderated after
> the first time or so. You've maybe never tried it :-)
> , but getting up
> for prayer at 3AM (might not always be the case, but almost
> always on
> the day after a rumschpringge), being reminded in front of
> your siblings
> and the hired hand that meekness and saying 'good
> morning' are pleasant
> habits in a family setting, milking (by hand)a dozen or so
> cows, then
> doing a couple of hours' worth of hot field work, then
> meeting a demand
> performance at the breakfast table, verbal participation
> and consumption
> of food required, all with a humongous hangover, it's
> not all that much
> fun. Very likely company is present, as these are
> gregarious people, so
> you are observed by many. There are sure to be 20 or more
> extra people
> for dinner (noonday meal), with a hour or so of singing
> before you go
> back to the field. No cross words will be spoken to you,
> but you will
> have many sly questions and reminders about proper behavior
> and maybe a
> whispered invitation to discuss anything that's on your
> mind while you
> work along a hot, sweaty horse all afternoon. You can be
> assured in
> such a case that the day's work will not end early, it
> having been
> carefully planned. Somewhere in the middle of the day, you
> keenly
> remember how much fun you yourself used to have at a
> "Monday
> get-together", laughing and talking and singing.
> Supper is late. And
> mandatory. Furthermore, since you undoubtedly slipped up
> somewhere
> through the day, you'll like be invited to wash supper
> dishes (male or
> female) because "Mom's had a big day getting
> everything around; she's
> tired." If you're really unfortunate, you might
> belong to a household
> that sometimes rotates leading evening Bible study and
> prayer; if so,
> it's surely your day to do it. All are sitting there
> waiting for you to
> commence, Bibles in their laps, bright-eyed, not looking
> tired at all.
> And all this is after you survived driving a chop buggy
> (nobody's dumb
> enough to let you take the good buggy to rumschpringge)
> drunk behind a
> horse that wasn't drunk, who knew how soon he wanted to
> get home....an
> experience in itself, not to mention the tractor trailers
> on the highway
> that has to be crossed. Once is enough for most people.
> The best part
> of all is that it will never, by anyone but maybe your
> buddies, be
> mentioned again.
>
> So even though these things may happen, they have a way of
> snuffing
> themselves out, or did. I really haven't kept up with
> the recent
> details since I'm gone. Things certainly made a
> serious turn when drugs
> came on the scene. Rumschpringge was, historically, seen
> as a time when
> a kid, before joining church, could 'feel his/her
> oats' before joining
> church and being for life restricted from the world. There
> does,
> especially in the PA and northern OH groups, seem to be
> more control
> exercised over things now; seems like the big problem went
> from east
> toward the west. I'd say this is where there will be
> some kind of
> change in the next decade or so, but actually haven't
> talked to any of
> the people who are having trouble in their communities,
> just know what
> I've seen go by me on paper, mostly, which is quite a
> bit but certainly
> not all! Now that I think about it I haven't heard the
> Dutch term used
> for some years by the IN groups, only the English
> "running around". If
> I can remember, I'll check that out when next I see
> someone who'd know.....
>
> SJ
> >>> I think the Mennonites/Anabaptists/Amish are
> an example of a
> >>> peaceful group that is not wiped out because
> it exists within an
> >>> insulated environment in a country where they
> have constitutional
> >>> protection. Inside of the USA might be the
> only place in the world
> >>> where such a group can survive.
> >>>
> >>>
> >> This is oft-stated as a "fact".
> However, they do not see it so.
> >> They have moved away from aggressors so many times
> that they see
> >> themselves as a people on the move. In this
> country, beginning in
> >> the late sixties, and accelerating through the
> seventiess and
> >> continuing now is a large migration of Amish and
> conservative
> >> Mennonites to Central America, particularly
> Belize, where they are
> >> currently courted by the government (don't
> have to have photo ids,
> >> their farming methods are advanced, and
> attainable, compared to local
> >> historical methods, they provide no drain on the
> educational system,
> >> etc). Here they have been badgered (over
> schooling, social security,
> >> plenty) in many places until it's actually
> embarrassing, at least to
> >> me, to think that my country behaves so. They
> are, from their point
> >> of view, being forced out.
> >>
> >
> > Thanks for making me realize this. I should have
> thought about that. I
> > don't think I really meant it as fact, but I see
> that I implied it.
> > There are even plenty of Mennonites in GA who came
> here not only for the
> > land, but for the schooling freedom.
> >
> > I would hazard a guess, albeit
> >
> >> only a guess, that it makes the counting a little
> more difficult,
> >> too, as they often make themselves difficult to
> quantify: easier to
> >> stay under the radar to be left alone.
> >>
> >
> > Smart move.
> >
> >
> >
> >> From our (world) point of view, all this moving
> looks like is that
> >> they are going from the frying pan to the fire,
> but from their point
> >> of view, it's the frying pan until it tips
> over, then a new frying
> >> pan......all of this is to them simply the way it
> has been since the
> >> followers of Zwingli were forced to meet in barns
> and caves in the
> >> 1500s: the norm.
> >>
> >
> >
> > You are absolutely right. I stand corrected.
> > I have clipped the remainder of your post, but I bow
> to it's truth and
> > it gives me a lot to think about. I see the point
> that you and Lynn are
> > making about "warring species"(I wish I had
> not said that that way), I
> > just hope that you can understand my belief that homo
> sapiens, as
> > individuals are a violent, aggressive species. People
> should be able to
> > play carom(and gosh I haven't heard any mention of
> that game in 15
> > years!) without being slaughtered...
> >
> > Bev
> >
> >
> >
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> >
> >
> > No virus found in this incoming message.
> > Checked by AVG - http://www.avg.com
> > Version: 8.0.176 / Virus Database: 270.9.13/1827 -
> Release Date: 12/3/2008 5:41 PM
> >
> >
>
> _______________________________________________
> Homestead list and subscription:
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/homestead
> Change your homestead list member options:
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/options/homestead/bobford79%40yahoo.com
> View the archives at:
> https://lists.ibiblio.org/sympa/arc/homestead







Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page