Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Rolf Furuli <furuli AT online.no>]

Dear Thory,

It is not correct that the whole issue hinges on the lexical 
understanding of a single word. I suggest that you read through the 
whole book of Jeremiah and compare all the verses that speak about 
the condition of Jerusalem and Judah during the exile when it kept 
sabbath, that the land was a desolate waste without men and animal. 
To claim that this condition continued after the people returned to 
Judah and started to rebuild the temple is special pleading.

Best regards,

Rolf Furuli
University of Oslo


> --- On Fri, 1/30/09, Rolf Furuli <furuli AT online.no> wrote:
>
> >  In the book of Daniel we find one saying that clearly is at
> >  odds with the universally accepted history, and that is chapter 9,
> >  verse 2. In this verse we learn that in the beginning of the Persian
> >  kingdom Daniel read about the 70 years when Jerusalem would be
> >  desolate. The same information is found in 2 Chronicles 36:21
> >  where it is said that Jerusalem was a desolate waste for a full
> >  70 years. Using the rules of lexical semantics, grammar, and syntax
> >  I am not able to see any other meaning in the two passages than that
> >  Jerusalem was a desolate waste for a full 70 years. Yet, the history
> >  leaves only 49 of 50 years for Jerusalem's desolate condition (and
> >  some say Jerusalem never was desolate). Is Daniel and the
> >  Chronicler wrong?
>
> It depends on how one is using "desolate." The Temple was destroyed 
> 586 and was not rebuilt until 516 in the 6th year of Darius I. That 
> is 70 years. Jerusalem is overflowing with people and buildings 
> today, but many here will tell you they consider it a desolate ruin 
> because the Temple has not been rebuilt. Are you saying Daniel and 
> the Chronicler understood desolate to mean strictly the period from 
> the destruction of Jerusalem to the 1st year of Cyrus regardless of 
> the condition of the Temple?
>
> Tory Thorpe
>
>
>      
> _______________________________________________
> b-hebrew mailing list
> b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/b-hebrew