corpus-paul AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Corpus-Paul
List archive
- From: Karl Schmidtke <karlschmidtke_1999 AT yahoo.de>
- To: Corpus-paul <corpus-paul AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: Re: Paul's Gospel
- Date: Tue, 17 Jul 2001 16:10:34 +0200 (CEST)
"Mesfin Atlaye" <mesfin AT idirect.com> schrieb:
> What "Scripture" meant to the NT writers is none
> other that the Jewish scriptures.
This, I believe is fundamentally incorrect as a
careful reading of this particular verse would
indicate. "Confident assertion without cognitive
assiduity."
> And 1 Tim. 5:18 seems to refer to Deut.
> 25:4 (LXX).
This, I believe could be described as a half-truth
which does not address the point at issue. Might I
suggest reading along to the end of the verse?
> Besides, the general consensus is that the pastoral
> epistles are not strong cases to argue on Paul's
> thought.
This misreads my original statement which reflected on
a previous consensus (associated with Jerome and the
Christian tradition more generally) in a rather more
nuanced manner than you seem to have appreciated. A
consenus, as Rudolf Bultmann used to say, is about as
useful in an argument as Charlie Brown's blanket: it
may give you security and help you feel warm, but it
should be discarded by adult scholars.
Yours in charity
Karl
>
=====
Karl Heinz Schmidtke
Pfarrerhaus
Leibensburg
[karlschmidtke_1999 AT yahoo.de]
__________________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Gesendet von Yahoo! Mail - http://mail.yahoo.de
-
Re: Paul's Gospel,
Karl Schmidtke, 07/12/2001
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Mesfin Atlaye, 07/16/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Harold R. Holmyard III, 07/16/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Elli Elliott, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, John Lupia, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Loren Rosson, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, David C. Hindley, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Zeba Crook, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Karl Schmidtke, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, John Lupia, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Hughes, Frank W., 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Loren Rosson, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Bob and/or Leonora Hunter, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Zeba Crook, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, John Lupia, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, JERRY SUMNEY, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Elli Elliott, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Jeffrey B. Gibson, 07/17/2001
- Re: Paul's Gospel, Loren Rosson, 07/18/2001
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.