Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

livingontheland - Re: [Livingontheland] Permaculture - Farms for the Future

livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Healthy soil and sustainable growing

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: "Tradingpost" <tradingpost@lobo.net>
  • To: livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: Re: [Livingontheland] Permaculture - Farms for the Future
  • Date: Sun, 17 Jan 2010 20:13:59 -0700


Well, that Penny Livingston is one I'm not familiar with, but she's got a
long CV in this stuff. And yeah, it looks like we're pretty much on the same
page.

Never heard of Pittman in nearby Santa Fe. I see Pittman at
http://www.ibiblio.org/ecolandtech/orgfarm/permaculture/permaculture-discussion-forum-archives/archive/msg00441.html
. But at $1,000 for a 2-week permaculture class, I gotta tell you, his
audience is too rich for my blood. And for the vast majority of Americans. I
know, it's oh so cool and green and trendy. And how many of his audience
(from Santa Fe, that says it all) ever get dirt under their nails. I know
Santa Fe, it's a 40-minute run up the road from here. I get ungodly high
prices for my produce from those people. They have a saying, if your wares
don't sell there just raise your prices. It has its good points. The best
hamburger in the U.S. according to Bon Appetit is on Old Pecos Trail north
out of town. It's so small you can seat about a dozen, and you wait in line
outside to get in on weekdays. It's named Bobcat Bite.

paul tradingpost@lobo.net

*********** REPLY SEPARATOR ***********

On 1/17/2010 at 8:12 PM Tommy Tolson wrote:

>Thanks. I was saying yes, yes, yes, but it seemed like there was
>still disagreement, when I don't see that there's any grounds for it.
>
>In "Introduction to Permaculture" by Bill Mollison and Reny Slay,
>there is a plan drawn by Vicki Robin (a famous Australian Permaculture
>teacher) of a Permaculture design on a 50'X100' lot that produces a
>lot of food and will produce it for a long time, because, as a
>designed system, it produces its own inputs. This book is widely
>available, but no longer cheap as it once was. It's a very good
>introduction, with several useful projects to build.
>
>In the scenario given, Permaculture fits the bill as, once learned,
>one can teach another, and cascade the effect to get millions trained
>in the basics of building self-supporting ecosystems that support the
>humans that live on/in them. This is one reason that Permaculture is
>such a great tool for restoring destroyed landscapes.
>
>The problem I have with that method is that, in my experience, only a
>gifted few teachers teach Permaculture so the ecological perspective
>gets through to the student and breaks them out of the economic
>paradigm, where everything has a price put on it. My teachers were
>Penny Livingston and Starhawk, so I got it, but by then I had already
>got it once from Richard Heinberg, one of my teachers at New College
>in Santa Rosa, who, I understand, has a Permaculture design at his
>house. I had also been a Green for about twenty years in 2001.
>
>Some things are beyond the human invention of price. A stable
>climate, provided for free, is one. But it didn't have a price so no
>one knew its value, until it was gone. The only way I know to avoid
>that error in the future is to learn ecology, which contains economics
>(and all other "disciplines"). Economics minus its ecological context
>and its political component is destructive, as the last half
>millennium demonstrated.
>
>"Permaculture: Principles and Pathways Beyond Sustainability" is very
>good at any stage of the learning curve (I learn more from it each
>read) at placing Permaculture in the context of what David Holmgren
>calls the thinking and design revolution. It's an excellent winter
>read. Mollison's "Permaculture: A Designer's Manual" is immense, and
>it's expensive, and it will never lose its usefulness, I think, as
>background information.
>
>Scott Pittman is still teaching the Permaculture Design Course at
>Pojoaque, NM. He's been doing it since 1985, and he's excellent. See
>www.permaculture.org
>.
>
>Smiles.
>Tommy
>
>On Jan 17, 2010, at 6:14 PM, Emery Mitchamore wrote:
>
>> I'm sorry, but you missed the point. It appears that a limited
>> introduction to Permaculture (perhaps from those selling courses),
>> has given you the wrong impression. If you have the time during
>> some of your housebound weather, and are curious, study it some more
>> and you will find some useful tools for implementing exactly the
>> methods and techniques you advocate. I've studied it enough to know
>> that there is no contradiction between your methods and what
>> Permaculture advocates. In addition, there is much to offer for
>> environments and circumstances different from yours. In fact,
>> Permaculture offers precisely the tools needed for the scenarios you
>> describe.
>>
>> On Jan 17, 2010, at 5:25 PM, Tradingpost wrote:
>>
>>>
>>> My response to permaculture is this: In the near term the urgent
>>> need is for millions to learn to produce all they can in as little
>>> space as possible. Why? The perfect storm - too many people, not
>>> enough good land, abrupt climate changes, rising fossil fuel-
>>> derived fertilizer & pesticide costs and falling income, and an
>>> economy running on fumes. And Peak Oil, but also rising prices in
>>> *anticipation* of Peak Oil. That's right. Nations hoarding and
>>> speculators driving up prices will be in the news. Full oil tankers
>>> are waiting to sell, lying off the coasts right now in anticipation
>>> of higher prices later. Even in recession now, global demand is
>>> predicted to outstrip supply by at least 10% this decade (except
>>> the IEA feels sure the Saudis can take up the slack. They can't).
>>> In theory a mere 15% shortfall can drive oil to $500 a barrel. The
>>> powers that be know this. They plan for it; the people don't. They
>>> know we are in the post-Peak "plateau" currently and long wars are
>>> being
>>> fought to control oil & gas producing countries. For obvious
>>> reasons they don't want to panic the markets.
>>>
>>> The effects? Big cities where population is dense will soon need
>>> all the space they can get for growing cheaply, with as little high
>>> priced food transported from outside as possible. Towns and rural
>>> areas will need the same since big farms hog most agricultural land
>>> and their fossil fuel input costs and prices keep rising. In town
>>> and country many people need to learn efficient growing in adverse
>>> soil & climate conditions, simply because there are too many people
>>> to feed and so much land has been ruined by industrial
>>> agribusiness. Topsoil depletion and water scarcity are widespread
>>> problems in agricultural areas. Most of us simply can't pick and
>>> choose where we'd love to have our "permaculture" design.
>>>
>>> I'm not foolish enough to draw up a timeline on this, but the
>>> direction is unavoidable. As in what we need to salvage some
>>> community food security. One of the sources for my comments was
>>> Heinberg's essay "Fifty Million Farmers". As for the "shift" you
>>> mentioned, my view is people will do what they need to do when
>>> forced to by economic conditions. One sign of this now is increased
>>> savings and less spending.
>>>
>>> paul tradingpost@lobo.net
>>>
>>>
>>> *********** REPLY SEPARATOR ***********
>>>
>>> On 1/17/2010 at 2:56 PM Tommy Tolson wrote:
>>>
>>>> I lived in a Permaculture design in Santa Rosa, CA when I was
>>>> married
>>>> to my first wife. From the second year, its food forest produced
>>>> food. We planted annuals on berms of adobe clay that we amended
>>>> with
>>>> shell flour, kept mulched with straw, and watered with drip
>>>> irrigation. Everything we planted grew like crazy. The marriage
>>>> didn't.
>>>>
>>>> I've seen the change that happens when people realize that part of
>>>> Transition is inner transformation. When I got to Austin, local
>>>> Permaculture was all about gardening, and I objected to that. It's
>>>> part of Permaculture but not nearly all of it. Permaculture is
>>>> about
>>>> building functioning ecosystems which happen to produce food for all
>>>> the creatures who make their living from that land. It's still a
>>>> lot
>>>> more esoteric than it should be by now. Stewart Brand, I think,
>>>> said
>>>> long ago, "We're as gods, so we may as well get good at it."
>>>>
>>>> I, too, think we've run out of time. The national government wages
>>>> wars for the oil to keep up our unsustainable consumer society. We
>>>> sacrificed four thousand dead and no telling how many injured so
>>>> ExxonMobil and Chevron could bid on producing Iraq's oil. When US
>>>> fossil fuel interests got the inside track at Copenhagen, it was all
>>>> over. We can't afford mitigation, but we can far less afford
>>>> climate
>>>> change.
>>>>
>>>> Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorganChase, wondered this week when the
>>>> recovery would start. Real recoveries are not jobless. The
>>>> economic
>>>> paradigm can't see ecological constraints.
>>>>
>>>> My hope is that people proactively engage the process now to create
>>>> the future they want to live after the economic paradigm falls and
>>>> the
>>>> ecological paradigm replaces it. Growing one's own food is, I
>>>> think,
>>>> a necessary element of getting through the crisis part of that
>>>> paradigm shift. But it's only an element. The shift itself is the
>>>> system, and I hope it can be consciously negotiated. We need to re-
>>>> learn how to build community, and learn how to create cultures that
>>>> support us in "being all we can be."
>>>>
>>>> But the big deal is the crash that the failure at Copenhagen and
>>>> corporate control of Congress almost surely guarantee. I believe
>>>> community will determine who lives and who doesn't, when the time
>>>> comes.
>>>>
>>>> Smiles.
>>>> Tommy
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Livingontheland mailing list
>>> Livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org
>>> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/livingontheland
>>
>> E. E. "Mitch" Mitchamore
>> www.hillcountrynatives.biz
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>
>_______________________________________________
>Livingontheland mailing list
>Livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org
>http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/livingontheland







Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page