Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

corpus-paul - Re: Re: C-P Summer Reading

corpus-paul AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Corpus-Paul

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: "Neil Elliott" <elliott AT igc.org>
  • To: corpus-paul
  • Subject: Re: Re: C-P Summer Reading
  • Date: Thu, 6 May 1999 15:26:12


A few RECENT works I've found stimulating:

Justin Meggitt, PAUL, POVERTY, AND SURVIVAL (1998)
Argues against "new consensus" that Paul and his churches
were "middle-class"; rather (like on M.'s estimate 99%
of the urban population throughout empire) they lived
just at subsistence level, therefore had to rely on
"Christian mutualism" as a "survival strategy." The
early chaps. on poverty and social structure are worth
the price of admission. (Amazon.com reviewers have given
it a five-star rating.)

F. Gerald Downing, THE CYNICS, PAUL, AND THE PAULINE CHURCHES
(1998)
Argues (as sequel to CYNICS AND CHRISTIAN ORIGINS I)
that Paul's self-presentation would readily have been
understood by Roman audiences as cynic-like, and that
Paul cannot have missed that fact. Also argues that
between "early" (Gal., Thess., Cor.) and "late" (Php.,
Rom.) letters Paul changed from a more "radical,"
Cynic-like social posture to a more subdued, conserva-
tive, Stoic-like one. Lots of good footnotes!

Winsome Munro, JESUS, BORN OF A SLAVE (1997?)
This work, published just after Prof. Munro's death,
builds an intriguing case that Jesus (and his family)
came from the slave class and were themselves slaves
in Roman Galilee. There is much useful material in
discussion and footnotes. There is ALSO a good deal
of begging-the-question, circular reasoning, and
arguments from silence--i.e. "since Jesus' slave status
would have been embarrassing and since the NT sources
are likely to suppress embarrassing information, the
lack of more explicit evidence 'proves' that Jesus was
a slave" (my paraphrase).

Despite these flaws Munro makes an intriguing argument
that Phil. 2 does NOT use "form of a slave" metaphorically,
or in some "theological" sense ("slave to sin," e.g., as
for DUNN in THEOLOGY). She argues Paul actually knew
that Jesus came from the slave class; the consequences
for her reading of Gal., especially Gal. 3:28, are dramatic.
At least her argument prompts a re-assessment of the sense
in which Paul describes Jesus as dying a slave's death.

Discussions, anyone?

Neil Elliott




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page