Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Shoshanna Walker <rosewalk AT concentric.net>]

Romans is not the word of G-d, it doesn't even allege that.

Our Torah was NOT given to the whole world directly, it was given to 
US, and WE are to be the transmitters.  YOU are not obligated to 
observe 613 positive and negative commandments, WE ARE!

The whole world did not stand at Mt. Sinai and receive direct 
supernatural Revelation, and no one but us agreed to receive and 
observe  it, in faith, even before hearing the obligations.

Romans certainly cannot explain Torah.  Only our keepers and 
transmitters of Oral Torah can.  That is not detracting from this 
list's purported purposes of trying to understand the SIMPLE MEANING 
of the HEBREW written Torah by means of linguistics.  But that is 
only the tip of the iceberg.  That is not racist. That is just a 
proud Jewess defending us against those who would like to own the 
Torah for yourselves.

Shoshanna



On 11/04/2007 01:24, Shoshanna Walker wrote:
> Hello????  BY WHAT RIGHT are you quoting Romans to explain OUR Torah?
By the same right that you repeatedly quote your "Oral Torah" to 
explain OUR Torah ("OUR" because it was given to the whole world, not 
just one ethnic group). You believe that your Oral Torah is the word 
of God, but we don't. We believe that Romans is the word of God, but 
you don't. We respect your right to quote the Oral Torah as long as 
you understand that not everyone accepts it. Please give the same 
respect to people who quote the New Testament.
...
> Is that your own gobbeldygook? By what authority do you proclaim 
> such meaningless nonsense to a list which is SUPPOSED to be above 
> religious doctrine, even though it is SUPPOSEDLY about OUR TORAH!? 
> Which only we JEWS have all the tools to know it? ...

You can assert this if you like, even if it is racist, but not here 
because this is religious doctrine, and as you rightly say this list 
is supposed to be above religious doctrine.
> ...
>
> I have been quiet for a very long time on this list - months - and 
> I have not promoted Jewish doctrine, as I have been admonished over 
> and over again, not to, but until I am removed and banned by the 
> owners in case they have an anti-Jewish agenda and are offended by 
> me, I will not cease and desist from defending MY Torah, AGAINST 
> YOUR FALSE NON-JEWISH DOCTRINE ...

If this is your intention, it is in deliberate breach of the list 
guidelines, and I hope the moderators will insist that you desist and 
remove you if you do not.
...
> A little respect PLEASE!

And from you!


--
Peter Kirk
E-mail:  peter AT qaya.org
Blog:    http://www.qaya.org/blog/
Website: http://www.qaya.org/