b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: "S. L." <lyosovs AT cityline.ru>
- To: <b-hebrew AT franklin.metalab.unc.edu>
- Subject: RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?
- Date: Thu, 19 Dec 2002 10:30:54 +0300
Trevor wrote:
>The drawback to Randall's approach is that BH lacks the breadth to
>constitute a real, spoken language. For that matter, as a collection of
>literary dialects, it would probably be appropriate to say that it was
never
>a spoken language as such.
I believe it is very true and important. Just think of Ullendorf's article
"Was BH a language?" and later contributions on the subject.
Serge Lyosov
-
RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?
, (continued)
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Trevor Peterson, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Vincent Medina, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Clayton Javurek, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, S. L., 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Peter Kirk, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Peter Kirk, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Peter Kirk, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Trevor & Julie Peterson, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Trevor & Julie Peterson, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Trevor & Julie Peterson, 12/18/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, S. L., 12/19/2002
- Fw: RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, S. L., 12/19/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Vincent Medina, 12/19/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Andy Warren, 12/19/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Andy Warren, 12/19/2002
- RE: "Non-Academic" Original Languages?, Peter Kirk, 12/20/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.