b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: "Joe Sprinkle" <jsprinkl AT tfc.edu>
- To: b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu
- Subject: RE: The OT?
- Date: Sat, 24 Aug 2002 12:24:47 -0400
Ms. Fried says: "The first thing I do with my students is to teach
them the difference between the OT and the HB.
I tell them the OT is the LXX!
(Not one of them has ever argued with me about it!) :)"
The way you define the Old Testament is close to true (but not quite) for
Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox Christians, but is definitely not
true for Protestant Christians. The LXX includes the Apocrypha, which
Protestants reject from being part of their Old Testament. Moreover,
virtually all modern translations of the Old Testament by Christians of
whatever stripe are based first and foremost on the Masoretic Text of the
Hebrew Bible, not the LXX. Though the latter is regularly utilized for
text-critical purposes, the Hebrew Bible is the main text.
The Catholic and Orthodox relationship to the LXX is complex. Here is a
chart that tries to spell this out that I produced for my students:
http://www.toccoafalls.edu/faculty/sprinkle/BIB453/The%20Apocrypha%20in%20Catholic%20&%20Orthodox%20Bibles.htm
The fact none of your students have ever argued with you reflects their
ignorance, not the correctness of your assertion. It reminds me of
someone's definition of a lecture: A lecture is when ideas go from the
notes of the professor into the notes of the students without passing
through the minds of either one.
Joe Sprinkle
-
The OT?,
JwReform, 08/23/2002
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: The OT?, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, jwest, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Ian Hutchesson, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Bill Ross, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Lisbeth S. Fried, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Dave Washburn, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Joe Sprinkle, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Nancy Johnson, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Peter Kirk, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Schmuel, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Shoshanna Walker, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Shoshanna Walker, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Shoshanna Walker, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, soren, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Dave Washburn, 08/24/2002
- Re: The OT?, Shoshanna Walker, 08/24/2002
- RE: The OT?, Dave Washburn, 08/24/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.