Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

ch-scene - Re: Message to Ralph Nader

ch-scene AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: RTP-area local music and culture

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: grady AT ibiblio.org
  • To: RTP-area local music and culture <ch-scene AT lists.ibiblio.org>
  • Subject: Re: Message to Ralph Nader
  • Date: Mon, 12 Apr 2004 17:15:30 -0400

Yes, that has certainly helped keep Israel on the moderate-to-leftward path that it's on.

You don't define "national service." Certainly there are a jillion things that people could do, apart from military service. But many of those things require initiative & compassion & a willingness to work hard, and/or a massive infrastructure of leaders/managers to train & point the way.

It's hard enough to get kids to pay attention & give a shit in college, which they are purportedly attending voluntarily. If you want more insight into the thrills of mandatory service, ask anybody in Chapel Hill who works with public-school students, or who works in a public-service field that might potentially be tapped by public-school students looking to get *their* mandatory-service requirement signed off on.

If you *are* talking primarily militarily, then keep in mind that with the exception of the world wars, I'm pretty sure that the draft never called up everybody who was eligible. And I can tell you that the military is neither equipped nor eager to deal with several million 18-year-old fuckups, either in peacetime or in wartime. Army of One, remember? The days of handing teenagers M16s and throwing them into foxholes are pretty much over. You gotta be able to drive a humvee while packet-radio-networking a laptop and navigating via GPS in a blinding sandstorm.

I'm not saying that we don't need *something* to both reacquaint the Youth of Today with the ideals of democracy, and/or to keep our public institutions accountable to the public. But to make such a thing mandatory & universal would cost more than converting our healthcare system over to universal single-payer coverage, and require more infrastructure, and we live in an era of Smaller Government, remember?

Besides, why get these kids' hopes up? They're going to be obsoleted in the workforce by robots in 10-15 years anyway; why delude them into thinking that they can make a difference & that they have valuable contributions to make to society?

xo

Ross

bendy wrote:

grady AT ibiblio.org wrote:

Yes, but Ralph doesn't care about all that stuff anymore. Now he cares about keeping our Young People free from being drafted to fight in Iraq:


I'm going to walk into a minefield and suggest that the only way America could avoid this sort of mess in the future is to have manditory national service, thus stopping the rightward drift of the military, and the notion that they're paid to die, should some muckety-muck have another unsubstantiated hunch.

I'm not sure I believe this, but I suspect it. No fucking exemptions for anyone, tho' you could do Americorps type stuff if you had conscientious objections, etc.

It's the *no fucking exemptions* part that would be almost impossible to implement, if history serves as a lesson (and it certainly has been for the last week or so....)

It's socialism, folks! Bring it up during the next Thanksgiving dinner argument with the relatives. It'll baffle 'em.

Bendy
-- ch-scene: the list that mirrors alt.music.chapel-hill --
http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/ch-scene





Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page