internetworkers AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Internetworkers: http://www.ibiblio.org/internetworkers/
List archive
Re: [internetworkers] OK to replace lost CD's with copied ones?
- From: David Minton <dminton AT mindspring.com>
- To: InterNetWorkers <internetworkers AT lists.ibiblio.org>
- Subject: Re: [internetworkers] OK to replace lost CD's with copied ones?
- Date: Tue, 23 Sep 2003 14:37:15 -0400
On 9/23/03 1:54 PM, "Gina Norman" <gina.norman AT nortelnetworks.com> wrote:
>> Thoughts? Should I post a list of the missing titles? Or would that
>> possibly land me in court?
>
> IMHO, legally, this would still be dangerous (if not illegal) territory;
> however, morally you're on high ground.
>
> To be on the safe side, I wouldn't *post* a list of missing titles; however,
> if someone said they'd be willing to help, emailing them privately would be
> less likely to cause trouble,
Note that I am not a lawyer (nor play one on TV), but I believe the DCMA
allows for a backup copy of music cds to be made under the "Fair Use"
clause. While this particular case would be having someone making a backup
for you after the fact, it may still be legal--especially since you have the
original packages.
I looked at some CD packages I have, and while they do not say you can make
a backup, they say "unauthorized copying is prohibited." This suggests there
are forms of copying that are authorized.
David
-
Re: [internetworkers] scotch (was many other topics)
, (continued)
- Re: [internetworkers] scotch (was many other topics), Victor Minton, 09/24/2003
- RE: is it iodine-flavored dirt, or dirt-flavored iodine? (was: Re: [internetworkers] OKto replacelost CD's with copied ones?), Jim Ray, 09/24/2003
- Re: is it iodine-flavored dirt, or dirt-flavored iodine? (was: Re: [internetworkers] OKto replacelost CD's with copied ones?), Steven Champeon, 09/24/2003
- RE: is it iodine-flavored dirt, or dirt-flavored iodine? (was: Re: [internetworkers] OKto replacelostCD's with copied ones?), Jim Ray, 09/24/2003
- RE: is it iodine-flavored dirt, or dirt-flavored iodine? (was: Re: [internetworkers] OKto replacelostCD's with copied ones?), Scott Lundgren, 09/24/2003
-
RE: [internetworkers] OK to replace lost CD's with copied ones?,
Jim Ray, 09/23/2003
- Re: [internetworkers] OK to replace lost CD's with copied ones?, Kevin Sonney, 09/23/2003
- RE: [internetworkers] OK to replace lost CD's with copied ones?, Jim Ray, 09/24/2003
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.