b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: "Ian Hutchesson" <mc2499 AT mclink.it>
- To: "Biblical Hebrew" <b-hebrew AT franklin.metalab.unc.edu>
- Subject: Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3
- Date: Fri, 16 Aug 2002 16:05:25 +0200
>Ian, I agree with you that there are six days of creation described in
>the structure you outline here. And I agree with you that the first of
>those days was probably not creation ex nihilo, that matter had somehow
>come into being outside that structure of six days.
Why do you think it had to come into being? And that
outside the six days of creation? which I have pointed
out before renders the inauguration of the Sabbath
meaningless.
>What I am suggesting
>as at least possible is that verse 1 is a brief account, outside and
>apart from that structure of six days, of how that undifferentiated,
>chaotic matter came into being.
The text doesn't say this.
>Several books of the Hebrew Bible (but not Genesis) start with WAYYIQTOL
>verbs. But they are part of an ongoing narrative history of Israel and
>start with the next significant event in that history.
Such as Ezekiel.
>A friend of mine
>has written a paper, which may be published shortly, on how the books of
>the Bible fit together in a framework using such verb forms and other
>discourse markers. Niccacci wrote something similar a few years ago, in
>Italian I think but that shouldn't be a problem for you.
Thanks, Peter, I'll see if I can find it.
Ian
-
My understanding of Gen 1:1-3,
Andrew Kulikovsky, 08/13/2002
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Yigal Levin, 08/14/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Polycarp66, 08/14/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/14/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Ian Hutchesson, 08/15/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Yigal Levin, 08/15/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Peter Kirk, 08/15/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Ian Hutchesson, 08/15/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Mike Sangrey, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Peter Kirk, 08/16/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Ian Hutchesson, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Dave Washburn, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Peter Kirk, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Dave Washburn, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/16/2002
- Re: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Andrew & Debby Kulikovsky, 08/16/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Dave Washburn, 08/17/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Dave Washburn, 08/17/2002
- RE: My understanding of Gen 1:1-3, Peter Kirk, 08/17/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.