b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History
- From: "Ian Hutchesson" <mc2499 AT mclink.it>
- To: "Biblical Hebrew" <b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History
- Date: Fri, 5 Oct 2001 08:32:03 +0200
>Ian wrote :
>
><Walter, I'm sure you'll note that at the time the DSS were
><written Greek culture was well disseminated in Palestine.
><However, there is almost no trace of that culture or of
><linguistic influence. At he same time new cities don't have
><long traditions. I don't marvel that there are no Greek
><cities mentioned in what some people are calling the
><"primary history".
Walter:
>Fair-enough, Ian. Why don't you "marvel" that the narrator, allegedly
>writing for a Hellenistic audience, didn't bother to explain that some
>cities had changed their names by Hellenistic times, and provide for them,
>like Josephus did, the modern and the ancient names ? He was concerned to
>explain Laish had become Dan, so why not the same concern for Hellenized
>names of older cities ?
Why should he? You might like it, but that's not relevant.
Ian
-
The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History,
Walter Mattfeld, 10/02/2001
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- RE: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Peter Kirk, 10/02/2001
- Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Greg Jordan, 10/02/2001
- Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Will Wagers, 10/02/2001
- The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Walter Mattfeld, 10/05/2001
- Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Ian Hutchesson, 10/05/2001
- SV: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Thomas L. Thompson, 10/05/2001
- The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Walter Mattfeld, 10/12/2001
- RE: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Peter Kirk, 10/12/2001
- Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Ian Hutchesson, 10/12/2001
- RE: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Peter Kirk, 10/12/2001
- Re: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Ian Hutchesson, 10/12/2001
- RE: The Case Against a Hellenistic Primary History, Peter Kirk, 10/13/2001
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.