b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: "David Stabnow" <dstabno AT lifeway.com>
- To: b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu
- Subject: RE: Written by Women.???
- Date: Wed, 21 Feb 2001 13:29:21 -0600
Liz wrote:
Samuel does not mean asked of God,
although it says that in the text.
In 1 Sam 1:20 the text does not say that "Samuel" means "asked of God." It
says that Hannah said she named him Samuel because she requested (_$)L_)
him from God. Perhaps she was taking the shin from _$)L_, attaching it to
_M-)L_, and varying the vocalization. It's a reach, but an etymological pun
nonetheless.
We struggle to understand the language straight, it wouldn't be a surprise
if we are slow to catch on to the intricacies of punning in names. Names
sometimes employ cultural obscurities and subtle logic. People who don't
know Qwerty would wonder why the typist named her daughter Pointesa.
Dave
-
Re: Written by Women.???
, (continued)
- Re: Written by Women.???, Raymond de Hoop, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Dave Washburn, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Dave Washburn, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Bruce Gardner, 02/21/2001
- RE: Written by Women.???, Liz Fried, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Raymond de Hoop, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Raymond de Hoop, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Bruce Gardner, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Christine Bass, 02/21/2001
- RE: Written by Women.???, Liz Fried, 02/21/2001
- RE: Written by Women.???, David Stabnow, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Dave Washburn, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Ian Hutchesson, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, David Stabnow, 02/21/2001
- Written by Women.???, Harold R. Holmyard III, 02/21/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Dave Washburn, 02/21/2001
- RE: Written by Women.???, M. Brody, 02/22/2001
- Re: Written by Women.???, Raymond de Hoop, 02/22/2001
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.