corpus-paul AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Corpus-Paul
List archive
- From: "Doug Ward" <DWard AT globespec.com>
- To: "Corpus-paul" <corpus-paul AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: RE: Jerusalem conference
- Date: Thu, 22 Aug 2002 09:24:49 -0500
Near the
very end of the letter he reinforced the point yet again by implying in 6:12
that James and the disciples were the actual guilty persons behind the
Crucifixion of Christ. This dark and hazy smear was broadened in 1
Thessalonians 2:15-16, to a smear against "the Jews," meaning against the
supporters of the covenant. This passage was the climax to one of Paul's
autobiographical passages, 2:2-16, and it, too, cannot be properly
understood unless one understands truthfully what Galatians was all about,
which is circumcision.
I contend that one cannot truthfully understand Paul, and the creation of
Christianity by him and his followers who wrote the New Testament, unless
one understands how frightful and dangerous a thing circumcision was
perceived to be by the adult Gentile males who became Paul's followers and
the first "Christians."
Eric Zuesse
cettel AT shoreham.net
Eric,
I think I can understand how frightful a thing circumcision was to the
Gentile men of that era, or any other era. But let me ask you a question.
If Galatians 2 is the Jerusalem conference, then Galatians was written at
least a few months after this conference. And if Paul broadens his negative
feelings about the Jerusalem party in Galatians to a larger smear against
"the Jews in I Thess. then how do you date these documents? This seems to
be a sudden, broadening of negativity in only a few months time, or do you
date I Thess. later than the current majority opinion of 50 0r 51 C.E.?
Best Regards,
DOug Ward
Wheaton, IL
-
RE: Jerusalem conference
, (continued)
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Loren Rosson, 08/21/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, RSBrenchley, 08/21/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, Bob MacDonald, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Bob MacDonald, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Steve Black, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, David Inglis, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Loren Rosson, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Edgar M. Krentz, 08/21/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Loren Rosson, 08/22/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Eric Zuesse, 08/22/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Doug Ward, 08/22/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Eric Zuesse, 08/22/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Hyam Maccoby, 08/22/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, David C. Hindley, 08/24/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Eric Zuesse, 08/24/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, Stephen C. Carlson, 08/25/2002
- RE: Jerusalem conference, David C. Hindley, 08/25/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, RSBrenchley, 08/26/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, RSBrenchley, 08/26/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, Hyam Maccoby, 08/26/2002
- Re: Jerusalem conference, Eric Zuesse, 08/26/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.