cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Development of Creative Commons licenses
List archive
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*
- From: Evan Prodromou <evan AT wikitravel.org>
- To: Discussion on the Creative Commons license drafts <cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org>
- Subject: Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*
- Date: Thu, 02 Dec 2004 22:40:03 -0500
On Fri, 2004-03-12 at 03:17 +0100, Wouter Vanden hove wrote:
> When creating a derivative work of a dual-licensed work, you need to
> pick a license, say GFDL.
>
> Then you have a derivative work, *only* distributable under GFDL.
> The same for BY-SA.
>
> But suppose you create two **identical** derivative works, one under
> GFDL and one under BY-SA. Then again, downstream users can pick either
> one of them to create a derivative work, if they know both versions exist.
So, you're saying that the way around the exclusivity of the GFDL and
the by-sa is to make two "different" derivative works, each under a
different license, but bitwise identical? And perhaps even occupying the
same virtual/real space? Yet somehow not "the same" derivative work?
That seems awfully hard to defend.
~ESP
--
Evan Prodromou <evan AT wikitravel.org>
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part
-
Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Evan Prodromou, 12/02/2004
-
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Wouter Vanden hove, 12/02/2004
-
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Evan Prodromou, 12/02/2004
- Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, Branko Collin, 12/03/2004
-
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Evan Prodromou, 12/02/2004
-
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Rob Myers, 12/03/2004
- Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, Evan Prodromou, 12/03/2004
- Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, Branko Collin, 12/03/2004
- Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, Jeremy, 12/03/2004
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
-
Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
wiki_tomos, 12/20/2004
- Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, Mike Linksvayer, 12/21/2004
- Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*, wiki_tomos, 12/20/2004
-
Re: Dual-licensing under the GNU Free Documentation License and Creative Commons *-ShareAlike-*,
Wouter Vanden hove, 12/02/2004
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.