Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Norman Cohn <normanncohn AT yahoo.com.br>]

Jim, I don't feel like taking part in this discussion and think George is 
absolutely right in closing the thread, as you seem to be conducting the 
debate with no regard whatsoever to evidence, sound scholarship and logical 
principles. You're clearly a very capable and smart person, endowed with 
frankly enviable energy, but your lack of logical consistency - your whole 
argument is circular - and regard to evidence compromise your thesis. And by 
all means try to make your posts SHORTER, cause I feel most people can't 
follow (like me!) such lenghty texts in the context of a discussion list. 
Best regards - NORMAN COHN - Sao Paulo Brazil.