b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: "Peter Kirk"<peter_kirk AT sil.org>
- To: <b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long)
- Date: Sat, 22 Jan 2000 00:29:24 -0500
Dear Walter,
There is a very simple answer to almost all of your arguments here:
they are simply arguments from silence.
I notice that in your quote Redford speaks of a "post-Exilic editor".
So is it really true that "he concluded... that Genesis was written in
the Post-Exilic period"? Apparently not; he is not supporting your
position that "Genesis is a Post-Exilic creation". I find Redford's
position, limited post-exilic editing, much more plausible than yours
- although I wonder why the editing could not rather be in late
pre-exilic times.
Peter Kirk
______________________________ Reply Separator
_________________________________
Subject: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long)
Author: <mattfeld AT mail.pjsnet.com> at Internet
Date: 21/01/2000 20:42
<snip>
Redford is an Egyptologist, he concluded on the basis of his research that
Genesis was written in the Post-Exilic period:
"The Egypt that shows through in the Table of Nations is the Egypt of
Psammetichos I and his descendants, the 26th Dynasty. To contend that the
Hebrews must have been familiar with Egypt from high antiquity is to belabor
a truism. But the post-Exilic editor was publishing for his contemporaries;
and the Egypt he felt obliged to explain for them was the Nilotic power of
his own time." (p.408)
My research, quite independent of Redford's, and following a different line
of inquiry (Madai's descent from Japheth) arrived at the same conclusion,
Genesis is a Post-Exilic creation.
<snip>
-
"Post-Exilic" Genesis (long),
Walter Mattfeld, 01/21/2000
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Peter Kirk, 01/21/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), kdlitwak, 01/21/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Jonathan Bailey, 01/22/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Jonathan D. Safren, 01/22/2000
- RE: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Niels Peter Lemche, 01/22/2000
- RE: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Niels Peter Lemche, 01/22/2000
- RE: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Niels Peter Lemche, 01/22/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Rolf Furuli, 01/22/2000
- RE: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Niels Peter Lemche, 01/22/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Rolf Furuli, 01/22/2000
- Re: "Post-Exilic" Genesis (long), Noel O'Riordan, 01/23/2000
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.