corpus-paul AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Corpus-Paul
List archive
- From: "Tim Harris" <tharris AT senet.com.au>
- To: "Corpus Paulinum" <corpus-paul AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: Humility & status conventions
- Date: Fri, 29 Jun 2001 17:44:39 +0930
Being a newcomer to the Corpus Paulinum, I thought
I might briefly introduce myself and indicate my area of research. I am a
doctoral student at Flinders University in Sth. Aust.. My thesis is on "'Count
others better than yourself': Pauline notions of humility and deference in
Graeco-Roman perspective". My starting point is Edwin Judge's distinction (which
I hope to test) between rank and status in Pauline social ethics (basically that
Paul accepted notions of rank as a 'given', but challenged status conventions
(how rank was employed ). My focus alongside Paul is on stoicism of the early
imperial period: especially Musonius Rufus, Epictetus and to a lesser extent,
Dio Chysostom.
My basic thesis is that humility (and similar
terms) has been domesticated in Christian thought, considered little more than
'being nice' and not getting too arrogant. Whilst stoic teaching similarly
condemned undue pride and arrogance, Pauline instruction on humility (esp.
Philippians 2) was much more radical, even subversive, in much the same way as
the cruciform shape given to perceptions of strength and weakness, honour and
shame. A whole value system is being challenged, with alternative notions of
strength, power and sufficiency (cf. Deidre Good on 'meekness'). I am also
exploring the relationship between humility, deference and
subordination.
I am interested in knowing of any other studies in
related areas, and especially of any papers or publications on the use of status
conventions.
In particular-
-any recent studies on Paul and Stoic social ethics
(the classic work is by Albrecht Dihle in RAC; I'm aware of most major studies
up to Engberg-Pedersen 'Paul and the Stoics')
-any work on 'HUPOTASSW', - is it necessarily
hierarchical, or possibly a recognition of an ordering of gifts or 'charisms'
under God & more mutually recognised?
-despite fairly extensive reading, I have yet to
come across a convincing and incisive treatment of what is meant by 'in humility
count others as better than yourselves' (Phil. 2:3). What does this really mean?
It obviously must be taken in reference to 2:6-8 (an exegetical minefield in
itself!)
Any suggestions or references
appreciated.
Tim Harris
email: tharris AT senet.com.au Dept. of Theology, (doctoral studies) Flinders University Rector, St. Matthew's Kensington, PO Box 56 Kensington Park, Sth. Australia 5068 |
-
Humility & status conventions,
Tim Harris, 06/29/2001
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: Humility & status conventions, Edgar Krentz, 06/29/2001
- Re: Humility & status conventions, Virginia Wiles, 06/29/2001
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.