corpus-paul AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Corpus-Paul
List archive
- From: "Robert Brenchley" <RSBrenchley AT aol.com>
- To: corpus-paul
- Subject: Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis
- Date: Wed, 5 Apr 2000 19:42:46
On 02/09/00, "JMAZHAM AT aol.com" wrote:
> To the Group:
I just finished Professor Goulder's book on St Paul Versus St. Peter:
A
Tale of Two Missions. Professor Goulder's theories put the "puzzle"
together
almost too neatly. I would be interested on the group's thoughts on
Professor
Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis.
Best regards,
Jim Day
>Michael convinced me of the outline of his theory years ago, but you're
right, it is a bit too neat to be true. Surely there were more than two
groups involved; Matthew thinks a lot of Peter, takes a very unPauline view
of the Law, but certainly isn't a follower of James, so where does he fit
in. Was there a Peter group as well as a James group? I see it more in
terms of a movement which had a tendency to fragment under the pressures of
the age, and moved into many of the various facets of Second Temple
Judaism, which was extremely diverse.
I feel that Michael tends to underestimate the Jewishness of all the NT
writers; twenty-odd years between the crucifixion and Paul's first letters
is a very short time to invent a complete theology from scratch! I suspect
he did what we all do, and rang the changes on what was there already. I
also feel that Michael underestimates the apocalyptic elements in the NT,
but then that's one of the abiding sins of the church.Or am I being
unfair?
Regards,
Robert Brenchley
RSBrenchley AT aol.com
-
Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis,
Robert Brenchley, 04/05/2000
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Ron Price, 04/06/2000
- Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Robert Brenchley, 04/06/2000
- RE: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Robert Brenchley, 04/06/2000
- Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Mark Goodacre, 04/07/2000
- Re: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Ron Price, 04/07/2000
- RE: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, JERRY SUMNEY, 04/07/2000
- RE: Goulder's Two Mission Hypothesis, Mark D. Nanos, 04/09/2000
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.