cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Development of Creative Commons licenses
List archive
- From: "Branko Collin" <collin AT xs4all.nl>
- To: cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org
- Subject: Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian
- Date: Fri, 11 Mar 2005 12:29:20 +0100
On 10 Mar 2005, at 18:41, Daniel Carrera wrote:
> There are also freedom-related issues. The CC-BY license is A LOT more
> free than the GNU FDL. Debian has major issues with it. Enough to
> merit a position statement:
>
> http://people.debian.org/~srivasta/Position_Statement.xhtml
>
> Contrast this with the CC-BY, where Debian feels that it is "almost"
> free. They agree that the intent is obviously "free". And they are
> just concerned about some details of word choice.
Could you expand a little bit on this, especially WRT what you
consider to be "free" and "freedom"? I happen to agree with the FSF's
position, where freedom flows downstream. Debian's Position Statement
however seems to think that only authors should be free and have
freedom (granted, I only looked at the bit about DRM before I turned
away irritated).
Perhaps you should use another term, because the words "free" and
"freedom" may be too confusing. I do not think I have ever seen two
people agree on a definition of these words.
--
branko collin
collin AT xs4all.nl
-
Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/09/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Todd A. Jacobs, 03/10/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/10/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Branko Collin, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Branko Collin, 03/11/2005
- Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian, Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Todd A. Jacobs, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
- Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian, Greg London, 03/11/2005
- Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian, Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
- Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian, Greg London, 03/11/2005
- Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian, Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Branko Collin, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Branko Collin, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Daniel Carrera, 03/10/2005
- Re: Define Free [was Concerns: CC-BY and Debian], Robin Millette, 03/11/2005
-
Re: Concerns: CC-BY and Debian,
Todd A. Jacobs, 03/10/2005
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.