b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: George Athas <George.Athas AT moore.edu.au>
- To: "b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org" <b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org>
- Subject: Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג
- Date: Thu, 23 Aug 2012 14:57:12 +0000
Hi Jesse!
I wasn't characterising your view, but Karl's. My apologies if I wasn't clear
on that front. Nonetheless, your view does not seem dissimilar from his, and
by your own admission you were siding with his view. I'm trying to understand
the logic that says 'could be' is more plausible than 'probably is'. It's the
difference between possibility (anything is possible!) and plausibility (not
everything is likely).
In terms of cosmology, I'm not reading a Middle Ages flat earth back into the
Bible. Quite the opposite, actually. I'm reading forwards, not backwards—from
antiquity into the Middle Ages. But as you say, the issue of חוג is a
linguistic one. I'm yet to see any evidence that we should be interpreting
this word as 'sphere'. I'm happy to change my mind on this, but please show
the evidence. I know that some later cosmologies seem to have viewed the
stars and planets as being embedded in spheres and orbs that rotated around
the earth (the 'rolling spheres' of the beautiful hymn, 'Crown Him With Many
Crowns'), but is there somewhere we can see this in biblical texts? Going by
semantics and literary contexts, I've yet to see evidence that it's there.
Appeal to possible future linguistic finds is not hard evidence, so I can't
base my conclusion on that. Possible future linguistic finds might just as
easily show that 'sphere' is an impossible translation. Who knows? It's
meaningless to appeal to presently non-existent evidence which may not even
show up anyway. Once again, I'm happy to be shown I'm wrong on this—I don't
have a particular vested interest in the meaning of חוג. So I'm certainly
open to your possibility. However, at present, I just can't see the evidence
for 'sphere' in the texts and, therefore, have to conclude that it is
implausible given the evidence.
The appeal to the pillars as metaphorical also needs some evidence to
overcome the seeming hurdles before it. Given that texts like Gen 1 see the
sky as a panel of some kind 'up there' that holds water behind it—a panel
which has windows in it that open, similar to the springs in the surface of
the earth (cf. the biblical flood account), such that a catastrophic deluge
bringing about an act of uncreation can occur—it seems eminently plausible to
suggest that something holds that panel in place. The question is, "What?"
Going by the biblical texts, it seems that pillars holding up the sky is most
likely not purely metaphorical, but rather part of the cosmological
architecture in the ancient mindset. We today read these 'pillars' as
metaphorical (we have to!), but I don't see the evidence that the biblical
writers saw them this way. In other words, the literary context suggests
something other than what you've proposed. I will admit that your proposal is
possible, but it doesn't in my estimation seem plausible.
Happy to be corrected. But some evidence please.
GEORGE ATHAS
Dean of Research,
Moore Theological College (moore.edu.au)
Sydney, Australia
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
bhebrew, 08/22/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
K Randolph, 08/22/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, Jesse Griffin, 08/22/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
George Athas, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jesse Griffin, 08/23/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, George Athas, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
K Randolph, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jerry Shepherd, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
K Randolph, 08/24/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jerry Shepherd, 08/24/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, K Randolph, 08/24/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, Jerry Shepherd, 08/24/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, K Randolph, 08/27/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jerry Shepherd, 08/24/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, Oun Kwon, 08/25/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, Jerry Shepherd, 08/25/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
K Randolph, 08/24/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jerry Shepherd, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
Jesse Griffin, 08/23/2012
- Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג, George Athas, 08/23/2012
-
Re: [b-hebrew] Circle חוג,
K Randolph, 08/22/2012
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.