Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Shoshanna Walker <rosewalk AT concentric.net>]

Interesting that you should know better than Ramban, Rashi, etc.

What makes you think/what qualifies you to know better?

On what basis do you contradict the Torah, to say that "Ehyeh Asher 
Ehyeh" is a "no-reply"?

Shoshanna




> Exodus 3: 15  "This is my Name forever"

The author of Torah, unlike Faulkner, did not customarily refer to
antecedents few dozen words apart. It does not seem likely to me that shmi
refers to yhwh. I think, shmi rather relates to "God of Abraham, etc." And
such designation is meaningful - ancestral God.

Besides, Moses never told Hebrews the name he asked for. Thus, evidently, he
got no reply, and ehye asher ehye is idiomatic refusal to state the name.

Vadim Cherny