Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

b-hebrew - [b-hebrew] PQD in English in 1 Sam 15

b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: <tladatsi AT charter.net>
  • To: <b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org>
  • Subject: [b-hebrew] PQD in English in 1 Sam 15
  • Date: Thu, 28 Apr 2005 5:53:35 +0000

The thrust of the story of 1 Sam 15 is that Ameleq fought
with Isreal when Moses lead Isreal out of Egypt. This
created sin that was unatoned. Two hundred years later,
God decided it was time to settle the score. God commands
Saul (through Samuel) to attack and kill every single
member of the Ameleq tribe in their city. God is dis-
satisfied with the status quo and takes the initiative to
bring things into balance. 1 Sam 15:2 reads

e&-r$) le) r&yl qelm( h&( -r$) te) yTdqP tw)bc hwhy rm)hK
.eyrcMm wtl(B jrDB wl

How do we translate *paqadetiy*? I will punish, I will
visit iniquity upon, I will settle accounts, I will pay
attention to, I will charge guilt, I have remembered, I
have marked, I have considered - are all options that have
been offered. Does changing the translation of the this
one verb change the general thrust of the story any?

In my opinion it does not. In the story God wants justice
for the sin of Ameleq against Isreal. The sin creates a
debt to God that has not been paid. Whether it is 2 years
old or 200 years old does not matter. The way to *settle
the books* (NLT's translation) is to kill all of Ameleq,
from old men to infants as well as destory their goods.

No matter how *paqadetiy* is translated, the point of the
story is the same. If you sin against God, you will create
a debt to God that someone must pay. That may be you, or it
may be your decendants or it may be your compatriots. It
may be now or it may be many generations later. This is
the same perspective in 2 Sam 21 (where the verb pkd was
not used).

Having said all of the above, punish seems to be the most
direct translation in the context of this story.

Jack Tladatsi





Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page