Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

sm-discuss - Re: [SM-Discuss] Project Lead Vote for the remainder of the 2010 term

sm-discuss AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Public SourceMage Discussion List

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: Jeremy Blosser <jblosser-smgl AT firinn.org>
  • To: sm-discuss AT lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: Re: [SM-Discuss] Project Lead Vote for the remainder of the 2010 term
  • Date: Tue, 15 Feb 2011 14:37:44 -0600

On Dec 10, Jeremy Blosser [jblosser-smgl AT firinn.org] wrote:
> I apologize I have not gotten the result out yet. I had/have email and
> other machine issues crop up. Right now I mostly have working email again
> but do not have access to my gpg keys yet to sign a result mail.
>
> The best unofficial result I can give right now is 6 aye, 5 nay, 2 abstain.
> As close as that is you can understand why I want to make sure I get it
> right, but I should have found a way to get a status out earlier.

I finally got my keys back a couple of weeks ago; since no one was asking
about this and the remainder term was over I assumed it was moot but now
it's being asked about again with the new vote so here are the final
results. Unfortunately I'm not sure this brings any closure because it's
very close and gets into some esoteric details of our voting policies.

The final vote tally is as above, 6 aye, 5 nay, 2 abstain. Our policy
states "Votes require a simple majority (greater than 50% of all votes
cast) to pass." If we do not count abstentions toward the majority
requirement, that's 54 in favor. If we do count abstentions, that's 46%.
Under most traditional voting systems abstentions don't get counted,
however our policy specifically says "all votes cast", which makes it a
count based on the total cast. That was done deliberately, with the
intention that abstentions would count so that NOTA votes would matter--we
technical people tend to want our NOTA votes to count, even if it means
votes fail and have to be tried again.

So the result of the vote is nay. I do not however think that has any
bearing on the new vote, since any lead can start those and no one objected
in a timely manner to ruskie calling it or continuing it.


Full results:

Voters:

Lead Developers: (9/11)
George Sherwood
Ladislav Hagara
Eric Sandall
Andraz Levstik
David Kowis
Arwed von Merkatz
Jeremy Blosser
Justin Boffemmyer
Jaka Kranjc

Developers:
Vlad Glagolev
Remko van der Vossen
Treeve Jelbert
Mark Bainter


Votes:

aye (6)
ea0cf631f7d16afdb42e47314c857870e34c650d07caecf6bc9723b7afe3e12d46aea61877556fac3134be9b83b31a7867c99b3dc674619b0e44a402021b787f
c6e20618f850a231cb39e87adc08685c9bc1713b393b1734e01ac3d4a7e3ce14a2c044a765ea02a8940dd93916f402f11c8ee86905c8bb02621ec66e4f86d2e3
9c724f3d2b444b8f4ad2ccfe20ce7b6cf8f459e4a2018a4c6150fa7b23203563d017a79577addd7bafdd250feb4300f103087a326ae7c856e30fe81dd195c272
581d6412334d6bbfaeabea14078b30d99253d28fa11ff8631230ba6f0aa286577b31af2785c0cd54c4460df1d35fe25f4e48b444bd4b45c496947dce98216fe2
12d06e1b3c227da9f6a968d6c57175027355f93eb6ade20e4150cb8b9aad58a39b4fbd58ebee0d906007443ad3266c7b7d965449dbe3ce2242664b1782333111
eba4d6145305f1f2ca3f2c4d8142d7d9ba964a07836364e065f7be300952ab8355203cda85e85afad56835511aefd3184567259f741e0d6fa2d3ddca2ce7ab3f

nay (5)
667705f99c11acdbc08da720b2f31c257b2a5dce72383b49984c132f6cf43b84a8508b1dac079cb5b6bb76d6ead6589ef6c962a9edfa27c0a70ecb22657cf73b
b5bea81522ebf39f659fa039315ccf9e56837daafce93b68908f0bfd4a774d3b6cd767ec1850f1ead7fa9c083e1769715626cd7f5fcb8bb775e06d567acd1d3d
3554a549704d6f20e6d0734dffe677cb8762b2838d816f1efba59b56b26e78e18ffeae829f6ba2346b308e3c8c86287532032b04b47b2fdda776849569bd2854
113f89e7c58383b08be722c116f63edd8500cbec18c5a5eff89e0765b7a07230b0004e6fa17d663800adc533e36405debe5a6bbd6e5fdb5809f86ddbcfc6fb52
0606d06b14a3988d24f93c125752ac11cf69bd8ec380cf519ad5b9311ff3f35fd8e1adff7b5309b32d52b1c0f85f0e95cc88f52b4ba918a075e213bf76dfa2ac

abstain (2)
5b9c3ca86de306f3fdf2d3b2823e277dca850787d0c2b4e502ecbdadc13625b145d1bd31a12bf1d5630cfc4dddd0086e21e493e9ccfd87c3dfdfc47649843698
b8a6b41f9056d0d464e96033aa95735b210bcdf68ab508e7c23b68a68178a399dcd727cd081be44f3aa244e1c4dbb32088d419de08d4a1d585ca51938c3023dc

Attachment: pgpoeuWYJvKKa.pgp
Description: PGP signature




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page