permaculture@lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: permaculture
List archive
- From: "georg parlow" <georg@websuxxess.com>
- To: "permaculture" <permaculture@franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: Re: plants DB - indigenious
- Date: Tue, 1 Jan 2002 16:53:37 +0100
hi flick:
you wrote:
> We whitefellas do all want, want, want and we want it
> yet to meet an Indigenous person who evangelises about Aboriginal
> culture
> It's hard having to confront one's own cultural baggage, especially when
i agree and resonate with you on the issues of cultural dominance, greed and
exploitation. but why is whitefella dominant? Guns, Germs, and Steel: The
Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond
(http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0393317552/qid=1009898173/sr=1-1/ref
=sr_1_75_1/002-7174170-6581606) was quite a revelation to me. as a biologist
he looked at it scientifically (methodically, by historical evidence, and as
unbiased as one can be), and clearly answered: it is not because of genetic
superiority. but quite as clear came up: it is not because of special
greediness, cruelty, or any other ethical inferiority either. all societies
of all races have been equally ruthless as soon as they got a chance to
dominate. and they all did so whenever they got a chance, with all the nasty
details right down to genocide, be it whitefella, blackfella, redfella,
yellowfella or anyotherfella.
so i am afraid the attitude you can observe in todays indiginous people is
simply a result of the fact, that at present they are the dominated (read:
raped, killed, exploited, colonized, dislocated, etc.etc.) ones, and not the
other way around as in: they are dominated because they are so
non-dominating.
i myself found this even harder to stomach than the cultural baggage - it is
the baggage of our species.
georg
-
Re: plants DB - indigenious,
1earth permaculture, 01/01/2002
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Bill Kearney, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, georg parlow, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Felicity Wright, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, georg parlow, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Bill Kearney, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Felicity Wright, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Pacific Edge Permaculture + Media, 01/01/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Rex Teague, 01/02/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, georg parlow, 01/02/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, georg parlow, 01/02/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Toby Hemenway, 01/02/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, permed, 01/02/2002
- Re: plants DB - indigenious, Pacific Edge Permaculture + Media, 01/03/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.