Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

nafex - [NAFEX] Wine Growers Declare War on GE Grapes

nafex@lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: North American Fruit Explorers mailing list at ibiblio

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: mIEKAL aND <dtv@mwt.net>
  • To: nafex@lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: [NAFEX] Wine Growers Declare War on GE Grapes
  • Date: Tue, 20 Jul 2004 12:35:37 -0500

Wine Growers Declare War on GE Grapes

Winegrowers declare war on genetically modified grapes
By GREGORY FLANDERS
Associated Press, July 9, 2004
http://www.santafenewmexican.com/artsfeatures/1672.html

PARIS - Many French vintners are up in arms about what they fear is another
threat to their centuries-old winegrowing traditions _ genetically modified
grapes.

Earth and Wine of the World, an association that includes nearly 400 French
winegrowers, is worried about a government research project to tinker with
grape genes.

It's a serious concern in a land where the average person over 14 drinks a
quarter-bottle of wine a day, and where genetically modified crops are often
derided as "Frankenfoods."

"It is of utmost importance that the future of our profession is not
determined solely under the influence of scientists, industrialists and
technocrats," the group said in a news release Thursday after meeting in
Paris to come up with a plan of attack.

The National Institute of Agricultural Research is seeking ways to make
vulnerable grapes more resistant to disease, and it plans to replant a batch
of genetically modified vines after a five-year pause.

"We're not persuaded that the tests will start with the maximum number of
precautions that we consider absolutely necessary," said Alain Graillot, the
president of the vintners association, which also includes winegrowers from
California to Germany.

"We want to be certain that there will be no accidental spreading, and that
any possible toxicity of the plants is completely ruled out," he told The
Associated Press.

A small crop of genetically modified grapes was planted in 1996 in eastern
France by the champagne manufacturer Moet et Chandon in partnership with the
agricultural institute.

But consumer pressure forced the company to dig the plants out of the ground
in 1999 and limit research to the lab, said Sylvie Colleu, an institute
spokeswoman.

After all, France is the land that made a hero out of Jose Bove, the
mustachioed farmer-turned-activist known for ripping up genetically modified
crops and ransacking a half-built McDonald's in 1999.

"In France, the consumers of wine are rather traditional, and many are
against genetically modified organisms," Colleu said. "And many
professionals feel that this could hurt the image of their brands."

The dug-up plants were frozen in a laboratory, and the institute is waiting
for the green light from Agriculture Minister Herve Gaymard to replant them.

Jean Masson, the president of the research center in Colmar where the tests
would be conducted, said the vines could be planted as early as August.

This time around, the institute has agreed to certain restrictions to ease
consumer fears, he said. No wine will be produced from the plants, for
example.

Winemakers have complained that there is a lack of dialogue between the
researchers and the public. Masson, however, said that he had replied to a
letter from Earth and Wine of the World that he had received in March 2003,
but that he had no response until a fax last week.

France's vintners have for years suffered a steady erosion of their
livelihoods by margin-squeezing supermarket chains, falling demand at home
and the growing popularity of Australian and American wines abroad. A
government crackdown on drunken driving has also battered domestic sales.

Worried French winemakers are currently waging another battle: trying to
loosen restrictions on alcohol advertising.

Their message _ that people should drink more _ has met with resistance from
doctors' groups, who say the French already drink enough.




  • [NAFEX] Wine Growers Declare War on GE Grapes, mIEKAL aND, 07/20/2004

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page