Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

livingontheland - [Livingontheland] Why Sustainable Agriculture?

livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Healthy soil and sustainable growing

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: "Tradingpost" <tradingpost@lobo.net>
  • To: livingontheland@lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: [Livingontheland] Why Sustainable Agriculture?
  • Date: Thu, 07 Aug 2008 22:30:19 -0600


Why Sustainable Agriculture?
http://www.indsp.org/ISPreportSummary.php

1. Higher productivity and yields, especially in the Third World

Some 8.98 million farmers have adopted sustainable agriculture practices on
28.92 million hectares in Asia, Latin America and Africa. Reliable data from
89 projects show higher productivity and yields: 50-100% increase in yield
for rainfed crops, and 5-10% for irrigated crops. Top successes include
Burkina Faso, which turned a cereal deficit of 644 kg per year to an annual
surplus of 153 kg; Ethiopia, where 12 500 households enjoyed 60% increase in
crop yields; and Honduras and Guatemala, where 45 000 families increased
yields from 400-600 kg/ha to 2 000-2 500 kg/ha.

Long-term studies in industrialised countries show yields for organic
comparable to conventional agriculture, and sometimes higher.

2. Better soils

Sustainable agricultural practices tend to reduce soil erosion, as well as
improve soil physical structure and water-holding capacity, which are crucial
in averting crop failures during periods of drought.

Soil fertility is maintained or increased by various sustainable agriculture
practices. Studies show that soil organic matter and nitrogen levels are
higher in organic than in conventional fields.

Biological activity has also been found to be higher in organic soils. There
are more earthworms, arthropods, mycorrhizal and other fungi, and
micro-organisms, all of which are beneficial for nutrient recycling and
suppression of disease.

3. Cleaner environment

There is little or no polluting chemical-input with sustainable agriculture.
Moreover, research suggests that less nitrate and phosphorus are leached to
groundwater from organic soils.

Better water infiltration rates are found in organic systems. Therefore, they
are less prone to erosion and less likely to contribute to water pollution
from surface runoff.

4. Reduced pesticides and no increase in pests

Organic farming prohibits routine pesticide application. Integrated pest
management has cut the number of pesticide sprays in Vietnam from 3.4 to one
per season, in Sri Lanka from 2.9 to 0.5 per season, and in Indonesia from
2.9 to 1.1 per season.

Research showed no increase in crop losses due to pest damage, despite the
withdrawal of synthetic insecticides in Californian tomato production.

Pest control is achievable without pesticides, reversing crop losses, as for
example, by using ‘trap crops’ to attract stem borer, a major pest in East
Africa. Other benefits of avoiding pesticides arise from utilising the
complex inter-relationships between species in an ecosystem.

5. Supporting biodiversity and using diversity

Sustainable agriculture promotes agricultural biodiversity, which is crucial
for food security and rural livelihoods. Organic farming can also support
much greater biodiversity, benefiting species that have significantly
declined.

Biodiverse systems are more productive than monocultures. Integrated farming
systems in Cuba are 1.45 to 2.82 times more productive than monocultures.
Thousands of Chinese rice farmers have doubled yields and nearly eliminated
the most devastating disease simply by mixed planting of two varieties.

Soil biodiversity is enhanced by organic practices, bringing beneficial
effects such as recovery and rehabilitation of degraded soils, improved soil
structure and water infiltration.

6. Environmentally and economically sustainable

Research on apple production systems ranked the organic system first in
environmental and economic sustainability, the integrated system second and
the conventional system last. Organic apples were most profitable due to
price premiums, quicker investment return and fast recovery of costs.

A Europe-wide study showed that organic farming performs better than
conventional farming in the majority of environmental indicators. A review by
the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) concluded
that well-managed organic agriculture leads to more favourable conditions at
all environmental levels.

7. Ameliorating climate change by reducing direct & indirect energy use

Organic agriculture uses energy much more efficiently and greatly reduces CO2
emissions compared with conventional agriculture, both with respect to direct
energy consumption in fuel and oil and indirect consumption in synthetic
fertilizers and pesticides.

Sustainable agriculture restores soil organic matter content, increasing
carbon sequestration below ground, thereby recovering an important carbon
sink. Organic systems have shown significant ability to absorb and retain
carbon, raising the possibility that sustainable agriculture practices can
help reduce the impact of global warming.

Organic agriculture is likely to emit less nitrous dioxide (N2O), another
important greenhouse gas and also a cause of stratospheric ozone depletion.

8. Efficient, profitable production

Any yield reduction in organic agriculture is more than offset by ecological
and efficiency gains. Research has shown that the organic approach can be
commercially viable in the long-term, producing more food per unit of energy
or resources.

Data show that smaller farms produce far more per unit area than the larger
farms characteristic of conventional farming. Though the yield per unit area
of one crop may be lower on a small farm than on a large monoculture, the
total output per unit area, often composed of more than a dozen crops and
various animal products, can be far higher.

Production costs for organic farming are often lower than for conventional
farming, bringing equivalent or higher net returns even without organic price
premiums. When price premiums are factored in, organic systems are almost
always more profitable.

9. Improved food security and benefits to local communities

A review of sustainable agriculture projects in developing countries showed
that average food production per household increased by 1.71 tonnes per year
(up 73%) for 4.42 million farmers on 3.58 million hectares, bringing food
security and health benefits to local communities.

Increasing agricultural productivity has been shown to also increase food
supplies and raise incomes, thereby reducing poverty, increasing access to
food, reducing malnutrition and improving health and livelihoods.

Sustainable agricultural approaches draw extensively on traditional and
indigenous knowledge, and place emphasis on the farmers’ experience and
innovation. This thereby utilises appropriate, low-cost and readily available
local resources as well as improves farmers’ status and autonomy, enhancing
social and cultural relations within local communities.

Local means of sale and distribution can generate more money for the local
economy. For every £1 spent at an organic box scheme from Cusgarne Organics
(UK), £2.59 is generated for the local economy; but for every £1 spent at a
supermarket, only £1.40 is generated for the local economy.

10. Better food quality for health

Organic food is safer, as organic farming prohibits routine pesticide and
herbicide use, so harmful chemical residues are rarely found.

Organic production also bans the use of artificial food additives such as
hydrogenated fats, phosphoric acid, aspartame and monosodium glutamate, which
have been linked to health problems as diverse as heart disease,
osteoporosis, migraines and hyperactivity.

Studies have shown that, on average, organic food has higher vitamin C,
higher mineral levels and higher plant phenolics – plant compounds that can
fight cancer and heart disease, and combat age-related neurological
dysfunctions – and significantly less nitrates, a toxic compound.

Sustainable agricultural practices have proven beneficial in all aspects
relevant to health and the environment. In addition, they bring food security
and social and cultural well-being to local communities everywhere. There is
an urgent need for a comprehensive global shift to all forms of sustainable
agriculture.





  • [Livingontheland] Why Sustainable Agriculture?, Tradingpost, 08/08/2008

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page