cc-uk AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Cc-uk mailing list
List archive
- From: Cory Doctorow <doctorow AT craphound.com>
- To: Rob Myers <robmyers AT mac.com>
- Cc: cc-uk AT lists.ibiblio.org
- Subject: Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?
- Date: Wed, 22 Jun 2005 12:03:35 +0200
I'm with Rob on this. It was a gag to highlight the craziness of the copyright system that keeps Happy Birthday in copyright. And if FreeCulture's cardinal sin is calling themselves "Free Culture Movement" when there are and have been people involved in Free Culture prior to their founding, is that so bad? Is it really necessary to arrange this firing squad in a circle?
Cory
On Jun 22, 2005, at 11:46 AM, Rob Myers wrote:
On Wednesday, June 22, 2005, at 10:20AM, David M. Berry <d.berry AT sussex.ac.uk> wrote:
This feels like a really bad office joke.
I think that's probably the best comparison.
It feels cliquey,
That would be a complaint I have. But if they'd sent the clip in private it would have got out and people would've complained about CC being secretive or whatever.
sounds
like it was recorded on someones office desktop computer in Microsoft
Office OneNote 2003 and mixed in the lunch-break.
The right to create doesn't carry a responsibility to create a great work of art. So some lawyers wanted to make a techno track of "Happy Birthday", had fun doing so, and it came out sounding about as you'd expect? Good for them. :-)
Somewhere, someone
in CC should have looked at it and said no way.
I find the idea amusing (I've no interest in actually listening to the track). And it is a good illustration of the problems of 'permission culture'.
Cliqueiness and low quality may work against it, but lots of blogs have picked up the ridiculous-copyright-law issue. On balance, I think this is constructive.
- Rob.
_______________________________________________
Cc-uk mailing list
Cc-uk AT lists.ibiblio.org
http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/cc-uk
--
Cory Doctorow
doctorow AT craphound.com
latest novel: craphound.com/someone
blog: boingboing.net
vanity: craphound.com
second novel: craphound.com/est
collection: craphound.com/place
novel: craphound.com/down
work: www.eff.org
Join my mailing list and find out about upcoming books, stories, articles and appearances:
http://www.ctyme.com/mailman/listinfo/doctorow
-
[Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Tom Chance, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Rob Myers, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?, Tom Chance, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Cory Doctorow, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Christian Ahlert, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
- RE: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?, Andres Guadamuz, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?, David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
- [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, Andres Guadamuz, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, Tom Chance, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
- RE: [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, David Hirst, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, J. Grant, 06/22/2005
- Re: [Cc-uk] FS vs CC?, J. Grant, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Christian Ahlert, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Rob Myers, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
David M. Berry, 06/22/2005
-
Re: [Cc-uk] CC going mad?,
Tom Chance, 06/22/2005
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.