cc-sampling AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Development of the Creative Commons Sampling license (or license option)
List archive
- From: Lisa Rein <lisarein AT finetuning.com>
- To: Chris Grigg <chris AT grigg.org>
- Cc: cc-sampling AT lists.ibiblio.org
- Subject: Re: [cc-sampling] More name
- Date: Mon, 15 Sep 2003 19:03:43 -0700
Hi Chris,
I think the point is to *require* transformations. Not to make them an option.
So as not to allow people to re-release songs without really contributing anything to them in the resulting derivative work.
thanks,
lisa
On Monday, September 15, 2003, at 06:57 PM, Chris Grigg wrote:
OK, so I just looked at the CC For-Dummies cartoon (http://creativecommons.org/learn/licenses/comics1 etc.), and thought I should offer that it seems like what we're after, staying consistent with CC vocabulary (esp. "No Derivative Works"), seems more like "No Non-Transformative Derivative Works," or, to invert that into a shorter and positive construction, "Only Transformations OK," or "Transformations Only". Obviously those are awkward, but maybe we can find a more graceful way of saying the same thing?
"Transformations OK" is nicer, but doesn't say anything about the non-transformative cases. You need to retain both the meaning that transformative derivatives are OK, and that non-transformative derivatives aren't. Ideas...?
-- Chris G.
_______________________________________________
cc-sampling mailing list
cc-sampling AT lists.ibiblio.org
http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/cc-sampling
-
RE: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?,
Kirkman, Catherine, 09/15/2003
- RE: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?, Chris Grigg, 09/15/2003
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?, Cory Doctorow, 09/15/2003
-
RE: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?,
Kirkman, Catherine, 09/15/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?,
Lisa Rein, 09/15/2003
- Re: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?, Glenn Otis Brown, 09/15/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?,
Lisa Rein, 09/15/2003
-
RE: [cc-sampling] Nation of Copiers, or, what to name the license?,
Kirkman, Catherine, 09/15/2003
-
[cc-sampling] More name,
Chris Grigg, 09/15/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Lisa Rein, 09/15/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Chris Grigg, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Lisa Rein, 09/16/2003
- Re: [cc-sampling] More name, mark / negativland, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Kevin Marks, 09/16/2003
- Re: [cc-sampling] More name, Kasper Souren, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Lisa Rein, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Kasper Souren, 09/16/2003
- Re: [cc-sampling] More name, Don Joyce, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Chris Grigg, 09/16/2003
-
Re: [cc-sampling] More name,
Lisa Rein, 09/15/2003
-
[cc-sampling] More name,
Chris Grigg, 09/15/2003
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.