Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Jay Frank <jif95 AT mac.com>]

George,

You wrote: "You know, Jim, I was almost going to agree with you (shock 
horror), until you claimed that Alter must think that Joseph is really only 
8½ years old. Shall I email him (Alter, not Joseph) and ask him whether that 
is his opinion? "

I, for one, am more than pleased to see talk of 6-month years set aside, but 
I continue to be intrigued by Alter's claim regarding the rendering of 1 
Samuel 15:31. I simply do not understand his insistence, particularly given 
Ruth 1:15 noted by Mr. Shead. Certainly it's difficult to believe that a 
person with his credentials would be so adamant without reason. If you could 
suggest a way I might contact the professor or, if you prefer, raise the 
question for me, I would be most appreciative.

Jay