Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

b-hebrew - [b-hebrew] PQD in English in 1 Sam 15 & XRM

b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: <tladatsi AT charter.net>
  • To: <ben.crick AT argonet.co.uk>, <b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org>
  • Cc:
  • Subject: [b-hebrew] PQD in English in 1 Sam 15 & XRM
  • Date: Sat, 30 Apr 2005 17:58:51 +0000

Ben,

Everything you say about XRM is certainly true.
Conventional warfare involves soldiers fighting soldiers
and leaving non-combatants (such as the elderly, woman, and
infants) alone and, if victorious, confiscating the spoils,
such as livestock. XRM is an extraordinary, non-
conventional action. In this case all of Ameleq, old men,
women, infants, and even livestock are attacked and killed.
Why was it invoked against Ameleq?

1 Sam 15 is quite explicit. It states that Ameleq is to
suffer XRM because YHWH wants to PQD them. YHWH wants to
PQD them because of the actions of the Ameleq tribe 200
years or so earlier during Exodus.

My note revolved around how to translate PQD in general and
in the context of 1 Sam 15 and Ex 34:7 in particular.
Specifically should it be translated as *punish* which
carries all sorts of theological implications. In
particular does YHWH *punish* the chidren and grandchildren
for the sins of their forefathers. PQD of course has a
wide range of meanings depending on the context.

If Ex 34:7 is not clear, 1 Sam 15 is quite clear on this.
The entire generation of Ameleq contemporaneous with Saul
is to die because of the actions of the generation of
Ameleq contemporaneous with Moses at the initative of YHWH.
Saul and his predecessors were quite content to wage
convetional warfare against Ameleq. It is YHWH who is dis-
satisfied with past practice and demands XRM.

The issue I was addressing was, even if one avoids the use
of the English word *punish* for PQD, that does not change
the overall thrust of the story. It is an unambiguous tale
of later generations suffering XRM for the actions of a
previous generation. So why not use the word punish, it is
what the ancient reader understood. Certainly it is this
conecpt, if not this actual text, that Ezekiel was
addressing in Ez 18:20. Certainly 2 Sam 21 is a similar
story with a similar perspective.

Jack Tladatsi




  • [b-hebrew] PQD in English in 1 Sam 15 & XRM, tladatsi, 04/30/2005

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page