Biblical Hebrew Forum

[Banyai AT t-online.de (Michael Banyai)]

Marianne Luban wrote:

>  There is an entire mailing list devoted to Rohl and his theories.  I once 
> joined it and got tremendous flack for making too many "points" against 
> him.  
> The opposition I received was virulent and hardly reasoned.  It was like 
> "This 
> is a list of Rohl fans and we don't want your arguments."  When my points 
> were 
> too sensible, the moderator, who apparently worshipped Rohl (a woman) 
> simply 
> did not allow them through. So I quit.  And I am not the only person who 
> had 
> this experience.  And that, sir,  is the other side of the coin of 
> intolerance.

Made the same experience on that list. After a number of critical questions, 
they simply closed me out of the list. While it may seem interesting to 
identify the good points in Rohl´s chronology, one might try this only by 
eliminating the many problems he creates. 


Best regards,

Bányai Michael
Stuttgart