[permaculture] The EU has a big vote on TTIP this Wednesday - make your voice heard now | openDemocracy

Lawrence London lfljvenaura at gmail.com
Tue Jun 9 22:25:46 EDT 2015

 The EU has a big vote on TTIP this Wednesday - make your voice heard now
  Jude Kirton-Darling
<https://www.opendemocracy.net/author/jude-kirtondarling> 8 June 2015

The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership, or TTIP, has received
an unprecedented amount of attention from constituents and campaigners.

This Wednesday 10 June will mark a crucial moment for the EU, when Members
of the European Parliament (MEPs) will officially adopt their vision of a
trade deal currently under negotiation between the European Union and
United States.

The message is clear: people are concerned that it could put our NHS and
public services at risk, lower our high regulatory standards and worker
protections and undermine the sovereignty of our governments. Others reject
any notion of a trade agreement with the US at all.

These fears have come to be symbolised by four letters. ISDS, or
Investor-State Dispute Settlement, is a system of private arbitration
already found in bilateral trade agreements all over the globe, through
which corporations are able to sue governments for passing laws that
threaten their profits. It does not abide by the same rules as national
court systems: in the para-judicial and often secret world of ISDS hefty
fines, at the expense of the taxpayer, are up for grabs by foreign

Examples of abuses of ISDS have rightly caused an outpour of moral outrage.
The Slovak government was successfully sued for renationalising its
healthcare system. The Egyptian government is currently being sued by
French utility company Veolia for increasing the minimum wage. While
Swedish energy giant Vattenfall is claiming compensation from Germany for
rejecting nuclear power.

My categorical opposition to ISDS has never wavered, and since being
elected as Labour MEP for the North East I have made fighting to see its
exclusion from future trade deals a priority. I am equally categorical that
I am not anti-trade: when it works in society's best interests, it can be a
vital asset to boosting local economies, supporting small and medium sized
enterprises and providing jobs and training opportunities. TTIP could
provide us with a unique opportunity to re-regulate globalisation.

However, politics is 'the art of the possible'. As trade negotiations are
carried out between the European Commission and the Obama administration,
my role as an MEP is a limited one. It comes in the form of a veto once the
final text of TTIP has been agreed. However if the Commission is to have
any hope of seeing TTIP through, it must listen to the Parliament.

EU Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmström has outlined her desire to include
ISDS in no uncertain terms and the majority of European leaders, including
our own Tory government, are evangelical advocates of the deal,
irrespective of its final contents. Unless Parliament is clear in its
opposition to secret courts, the TTIP we don’t want is almost certainly the
one we will get.

This is why what we do this week matters. On Wednesday, for the first time
since the European elections, MEPs will set out red-lines in advance of a
final vote on TTIP.

The basic text that will be voted on this Wednesday already contains key
protections, notably on public services, labour safeguards and regulation,
which were won by MEPs in the trade committee a week ago. However the
wording on ISDS is not as strong as it needs to be. Therefore, I have
ensured that Parliament will get the chance to vote on amendments opposing
ISDS. My party has laid down amendment 115, which states that ISDS is “not
necessary”. Amendment 27 <http://start.groenlinks.nl/ttip/uk/> is an even
stronger cross-party amendment that I co-ordinated with the Greens, which
states explicitly that ISDS “must be opposed”.

Furthermore, while we have called for a full carve out of public services
from the scope of the agreement, the trade committee report calls for a
'hybrid list' for services - combining positive and negative listing. In
order to guarantee that TTIP does not accelerate the privatisation of
public services, I believe that a 'positive list' for service offers is
necessary - meaning that only what is explicitly on the negotiating table
is open for trade.  Therefore, I'll be advocating support for another
amendment (Amendment 13
by the Greens, GUE and Five Star MEPs) which reintroduces this principle.

Getting these amendments through will be tough: the Socialists and
Democrats group in the Parliament, of which Labour MEPs are members, do not
command a majority. We are instead faced with a near-majority of pro-TTIP
and -ISDS conservatives and liberals, plus the broadly abstentionist UKIP
and fascist Members and an unconditional rejection of TTIP from the far

Before Wednesday's vote, I will do everything I can, supported by my
Socialist and Democrat colleagues, to convince as many MEPs as possible to
break ranks and support our amendments. The challenge will then be to get
an overall majority in support of a resolution that rejects ISDS.

But to do this we need your help.  A final push from the public, a final
outcry against secret courts and a declaration of support for progressive
values and key protections could make all the difference. I urge you all to
contact your MEP - by phone, email or social media - and explain why their
support is so crucial. Wednesday will see democracy in action; make sure
your voice is heard.

More information about the permaculture mailing list