[permaculture] BBC NEWS | Science/Nature | Charity attacks rush for biofuels

Lawrence F. London, Jr. lfl at intrex.net
Fri Jun 29 17:27:47 EDT 2007

Last Updated: Friday, 29 June 2007, 09:42 GMT 10:42 UK
Charity attacks rush for biofuels
By Roger Harrabin
BBC Environment Analyst

Filling up with biofuels in California Image: Getty Images
The rush for biofuels could have a major environmental impact
A furious attack on the drive to grow more biofuels has been launched by a charity supporting poor farmers in developing 

The charity - called Grain - says their research shows the rush for biofuels is causing much more environmental and 
social damage than previously realised.

Biofuels from crops are being heavily promoted by the US and Europe as a welcome solution to climate change.

In theory their emissions are much lower than from fossil fuels.

But the report from the charity Grain amplifies recent warnings from the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) 
that some biofuels produce hardly any carbon savings at all.

The UN says basic food prices for poor countries are being pushed up by competition for land from biofuels.

Name change

The Grain report says its research shows show that governments and biofuels firms in developing countries are 
collaborating to push hundreds of thousands of indigenous people and peasant communities off their land.

Barley (Image: National Non-Food Crops Centre)

Biofuel 'will not cause hunger'
Grain says: "The numbers involved are mind-boggling. The Indian government is talking of planting 14 million hectares of 
land with jatropha.

"The Inter-American Development Bank says that Brazil has 120 million hectares that could be cultivated with agrofuel 
crops; and an agrofuel lobby is speaking of 379 million hectares being available in 15 African countries. We are talking 
about expropriation on an unprecedented scale."

It points out that one of the main causes of global warming is agro-industrial farming itself, thanks mainly the use of 
chemical fertilisers which introduce nitrous oxide into the air.

The group says the media has been spun into using the attractive term biofuels - and wants them referred to as 
"agro-fuels" instead.

The plant fuel industry accepts that there is a limit to the energy to be obtained from crops - but believes plant fuels 
can be produced sustainably on a large scale. The EU wants to see at least 10% of road fuel derived from plants by 2020.

Oil firms believe this target is achievable using farm surpluses combined with fuel digested by bacteria from waste - so 
called second generation biofuels.

But their economic calculations do not include competition for feedstock from power firms wanting biofuel for combined 
heat and power - which produces much more energy more economically than liquid fuel.

The UK government's climate envoy John Ashton recently told BBC News: "The policy on biofuels is currently running ahead 
of the science."
Industry experts debate the use of biofuels

'Green' fuel plant plans unveiled
26 Jun 07 |  Humber
Biofuels 'will push up oil price'
06 Jun 07 |  Business
Environmental warning on biofuels
13 May 07 |  Science/Nature


More information about the permaculture mailing list