[permaculture] Shiva / EARTH DEMOCRACY THRIVES IN NANDIGRAM / May 08

Kirby Fry peace at totalaccess.net
Tue Jun 26 22:00:42 EDT 2007

I first saw Vandana Shiva speak in San Fransisco at a Bioneers Conference
around 1995, along with Bill Mollison, John Jeavans and Paul Hawkins.

Her hard hitting political and economic reporting and writting, as well as
her compasion for the plight of agriculture and rural peoples in India are
second to none.

This story, fortunately, plants a seed of hope about how people can come
together when they are forced to stand up for their community and it's
natural resources.


* * * * *

ZNet Commentary
By Vandana Shiva

Nandigram a little known corner of Bengal, near the mouth of the Ganges
river suddenly entered the nations consciousness in early 2007.

The fertile land of Nandigram had been identified as a Special Economic Zone
(Zone) for a chemical hub to be run by the Salim Group. The Salim group is
named after its founder Liem Sior Liong, alias Sordono Salim. In 1965, when
Suharto overthrew Saekarno, Salim emerged as a crony who helped build
Suharto's $16 billion assets. In the 1980's and 1990's during Indonesia's
oil boom, Salim set up the Bank of Central Asia. He set up noodle, flour and
bread businesses. He set up Indomobil Sukses Interantional to make cars,
Indo cement Tunggal Prakasa to make cement. Altogether he held 500 companies
in Indonesia. This is the group that was trying to grab the land of farmers
in Nandigram.

Nandigram was chosen because it is next to Haldia, a major port. SEZ's are
tax free zones, where no law of the land applies - no environmental law, no
labour law, no Panchayati Raj law for local governance. SEZ's were created
in 2006 through the SEZ Act of 2005, which allowed the government to
appropriate farmers land and hand it over to corporations.

But the small and landless peasants of Nandigram stood up in revolt. They
formed the Bhoomi Uched Pratirodh Samiti (the Movement against land grab)
and refused to give up their land. In January, 2007 the first violence
against the movement took place. On March 14th, 17 people were killed. On
29th April, another five lost their lives.

I was in Nandigram on 28th and 29th of April to pay homage to the martyr's
of Nandigram and to work with the farmers to give them Navdanya seeds for
setting up seed banks and starting organic farming. The farmers of Nandigram
had succeeded in driving out Salim's chemical hub. I felt it was appropriate
that we work together to make Nandigram a chemical free organic zone and the
local communities were willing. All day we sat together and made plans while
shootouts and bombing was taking place a few miles away. And during my visit
to Nandigram I witnessed the practise of Earth Democracy in its most
sophisticated form.

Nandigram's Living Economy

Nandigram is rich in soil, water and biodiversity, the real capital of
communities. Each village has its ponds, making for water sovereignty. Each
farm is a multi functional production unit, producing "paan", coconut, rice,
bananas, papaya, drumstick and the richest diversity of vegetables I have
seen or tasted. In fact, during our meeting, the village square blossomed
into a farmers market - with farmers selling four kinds of potatoes, eight
kinds of bananas, gur (sugar) made from date palm and Palmyra palm.

Farmers markets like the one in Nandigram need no oil, no Walmart, no
Reliance, no middlemen. Farmers are traders, sellers and the buyers. The
market is self organised. The community organizes itself for trade. There is
no Government license raj, no corporate control. This is the real free
market, the real economic democracy.

The rich biodiversity of Nandigram supports a rich productivity. In
conventional measurement, based on monocultures, industrial agriculture is
presented as being more productive because inputs are not counted, nor is
the destruction of biodiverse outputs and the soil, water and air. In a
biodiversity assessment, the biodiversity dense small farms of Nandigram are
much more productive than the most chemical and energy intensive industrial

The lunch the community cooked for us was the most delicious food we have
eaten - greens from the fields, dum-aloo made from indigenous potatoes,
brinjal that melted in the mouth - and of course for the fish eaters the
inevitable fish curry of Bengali cuisine. All other meals we had in Calcutta
or on the way to Nandigram in fancy restaurants were costly but inedible.

Nandigram has a food richness that big cities have lost. These are not
impoverished, destitute communities but proud and self-reliant communities.
In fact their self reliance was the ground of their resistance.

Nandigram is a post oil economy. Cycles, and cycle rickshaws are the main
mode of transport. That is why when the Government unleashed violence
against the people of Nandigram, they dug up the roads so no police or
Government vehicle could enter. Their freedom from oil allowed them to
defend their land freedom. Their living economy allwed them to have a living
democracy. This is the practice of living economy, of Gandhi's "Swadesh".

Living Democracy

The living democracy in Nandigram allowed the communities to resist. Many
farmers used to be members of CPM but in their resistance to land they
transcended party lives. The Land Sovereignty Movement in Nandgram is
totally self organised. There has been an attempt to present the land
conflict a party conflict.

However, it is a conflict between global capital and local peasants, and the
peasants have got organised because defending land is not a new issue in
Nandigram. Peasants of the region participated in the revolt against East
Inida Company in 1857. Nandigram is a celebration of 150 years of India's
first movement of independence from corporate rule with a new movement for
freedom from corporate control. Nandigram was also the site of the Tebhaga
Movement for Land Rights after the Great Bengal Famine. One can only enter
Nandigram as a guest of the community - with their consent and their
clearance. There is a high level of self-organisation, with women and
children, old and young all involved in keeping watch for unwanted
outsiders. Real democracy and living democracy, Gandhi's "Swaraj", is the
capacity of self-organise.

Living Culture

The real strength of the people of Nandigram is their living culture - an
agrarian culture, the culture of the land. This culture is common to the
Hindus and the Muslims. Nandigram is strong because these community has not
been divided by communal forces and the forces of religious fundamentalism.
Hindus and Muslims practise their diverse faiths, but are part of one
community. Even in the struggle against the SEZ and Salim, they have fought
as one. Their identity with the land, their earth identity binds them

I have come away from Nandigram humbled and inspired. These are the elements
of Earth Democracy we need to defend and protect from the violence and greed
of corporate globalisation.

More information about the permaculture mailing list