[permaculture] "thirsty " trees....

Ute Bohnsack sustag at eircom.net
Mon Sep 9 04:31:42 EDT 2002

Dear all,
I haven't followed this thread closely, so accept my apologies if I
write something that has been mentioned before.
There are situations where trees are undesirable because of their
'pumping' action. Raised bogs (peatlands) in Europe would be such an
example. Many raised bogs in e.g. Germany, Netherlands, Scotland,
Ireland have been negatively impacted on by drainage, often at the
margins (with encroaching development, intensification of farming
practices, peat extraction for fuel or horticulture). The slightly drier
conditions resulting from this drainage favour the establishment of
(typically) birch trees which are opportunists when it comes to water
supply. This means that they can deal with dry conditions but if water
is abundant they 'pump' and dry out the bog even more. Restoration
measures for such peatlands include the removal of the birch trees and
the blocking of drains. Now, this is a situation found in a cool,
temperate climate with relatively high rainfall.
There are also situations where non-native trees can cause damage, such
as eucalyptus plantations in arid regions where they compete with native
vegetation for water.
I guess one has to try and get quite detailed information on the local
ecology and ecosystems and/or observe natural ecosystems well, before
one can judge whether certain trees are beneficial or not in a given

My 2 Euro worth.

CHINAGRVE at aol.com wrote:
> I just joined the group.  I have 40 acres of land in Abo near Mountainair, NM - juniper, pinyon, cactus rocky land.  The forest service is always telling us that if we cut down our juniper it would help retain water on the land.  This did not really make sense to me so I was glad to read your post Kirby.   Because of the low rainfall, some areas near me where they have cleared the juniper are just parched earth.
> Where my house sits if I dig one foot down I hit a limestone shelf.  Any suggestions for plantings  and soil improvement would help.  The soil under the trees is pretty good but otherwise its pretty bad so I've just been planting wildflowers under the trees.
> Marilyn
> _______________________________________________
> permaculture mailing list
> permaculture at lists.ibiblio.org
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/permaculture

More information about the permaculture mailing list