...
Peter, I disagree with your statement that a Wayyiqtol verb cannot be
preceded by a subordinate clause. Gen 1,1-3 is an example! The fact
that I can't mention other examples right now means I owe you one ;)
...
If we would say that ברא is the main verb, then we have two problems:
first we have to solve the fact that בראשית is vocalised b'reshit and
not ba-reshit. If we say that the masoretes made a mistake, this
amounts to insult. ...
...
The Jewish tradition (using the MT itself all the time) does
acknowledge that it *seems* that G"d faced a number of "tools" to
create the earth with, but it has found answers in stead of emending
the MT. One of the answers is that in Tora there is "no early or
late", i.e. the real chronology of creation is not what we read in
Gen. 1. Midrash B'reshit Rabba states that the creation of the several
things described "were not specified" לא פירש and then finds places in
other parts of Tanakh that do specify how that might have happened.
Other traditions read בראשית creatively, such as "with [the sephira]
"Reshit" He created...," (here we are approaching the mystical
sphere); but nowhere have I found midrashim emending the text. If
there are, I would like to hear about it.
The second problem then, if we turn ברא [bara] into the main verb, is
that the other main verbs yet to come are all wayyiqtol verbs. If we
are of the opinion that a wayyiqtol verb (the traditional view)
follows up on an earlier, already told event/action, then how does
ויאמר wayyomer follow up on ברא bara? First it says that G"d created
"heaven and earth", in other words, "everything", and then it goed on
describing al the things that happened? I don't think so.
To me, the very fact that the first main verb in the first main clause
of the Hebrew Bible begins with "(G"d) said" is simply great. "Speech"
and "word" are so important in the Bible that it is hardly a
coincidence that the first thing G"d ever "did" (according to the
Bible of course) when He started creating, was to "speak". Then, no
less impressive is that the first "thing" that was created according
to Genesis is "light". Light in all religions is the highest symbol
for the divine. There is no better way of trying to approach what the
idea "G"d" might mean, than to use the image of light.
In other words, from both a syntactical and a religious point of view,
the understanding of Gen 1,3 ויאמר wayyomer as the first main verb
seems much better.
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.