cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Development of Creative Commons licenses
List archive
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works
- From: "Greg London" <email AT greglondon.com>
- To: "Discussion on the Creative Commons license drafts" <cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org>
- Subject: Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works
- Date: Thu, 5 May 2005 10:07:24 -0400 (EDT)
Evan Prodromou said:
> Case 2:
>
> Charlie makes a work and offers it to recipients under the terms of
> License U or, at their option, License V.
>
> License U: "You may make and distribute derivative works if they are
> made available under License U and no other."
> License V: "You may make and distribute derivative works if they are
> made available under License V and no other."
I think this is the root of confusion.
A license cannot prohibit the author from making the same
work available under a different license.
Copyleft and ShareAlike don't work that way.
GNU-GPL requires that any derivative also be GNU-GPL.
CC-SA requires that any derivative also be CC-SA.
Neither prohibits the existence of the other derivative.
You really have to think of it as two completely separated
works, each with their own license.
Alice
|
'--> GNU-GPL --> (Bob) GNU-GPL
|
`--> CC-SA --> (Bob) CC-SA
When Bob applies his modification to Alice's GNU-GPL version,
nothing in the license prevents him from making ANOTHER version
of the work available. If Alice and Bob both agreed, they could
even sell a proprietary version to microsoft that would be free
of any copyleft restrictions.
So, Bob takes his derivative and applies it to Alice's CC-SA version.
Nothing in the CC-SA license prevents Bob from making the work
available under a dfferent license (including selling it to
Microsoft), so it allows him to license the work GNU-GPL.
Bob can apply the SAME modiications to Alice's work,
once to teh GNU-GPL version, once to the CC-SA version.
--
Bounty Hunters: Metaphors for Fair IP Law.
http://www.greglondon.com/bountyhunters/
-
[gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Dave Turner via RT, 05/04/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/04/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Greg London, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/05/2005
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, Greg London, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Wouter Vanden hove, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
drew Roberts, 05/05/2005
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, Evan Prodromou, 05/05/2005
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, drew Roberts, 05/06/2005
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, wiki_tomos, 05/05/2005
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, drew Roberts, 05/06/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
drew Roberts, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Greg London, 05/05/2005
-
Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works,
Evan Prodromou, 05/04/2005
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: [gnu.org #238740] Derivatives of dual-licensed Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike and GFDL works, Evan Prodromou via RT, 05/04/2005
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.