Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

cc-gr - [Cc-gr] fyi: Copyright extension is out of tune with reality...

cc-gr@lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: [CC-GR]

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: "Theodoros G. Karounos" <karounos@mail.ntua.gr>
  • To: a_tsingos@yahoo.gr, aferti@berkeley.edu, alexandra@marinos.com.gr, aliense@hol.gr, andrius3d@gmail.com, cmeimetis@antcor.com, cminos@onlinelearning.gr, d.nestoris@observatory.gr, dimitri@globeent.com, dimitris.labropoulos@consulting-gem.com, ediniakos@hotmail.com, efthymios.lalas@alhellas.gr, eleni.kosta@law.kuleuven.be, evangelia_vagena@yahoo.com, evretech@hol.gr, galas@tee.gr, gina_kotroni@klclawfirm.com, hgb@mills.gr, igiannar@media.uoa.gr, inahos@acn.gr, ioannis_valmas@yahoo.gr, kafeza.e@dsa.gr, kochristod@yahoo.gr, m.markellou@voila.fr, mail@georganta.eu, margerogian@aua.gr, messimeris@gmail.com, nverras@yahoo.gr, phsept@hotmail.com, s.karanastasis@observatory.gr, sintoris@gmx.net, spiropou@otenet.gr, st_karapapa@hotmail.com, starantzis.k@dsa.gr, tatianasinodin@hotmail.com, vasilg@grnet.gr, zoikard@the.forthnet.gr, Alexios Zavras <zvr+ebf@zvr.gr>, Elena Tavlaki <elena.tavlaki@gmail.com>, Georgios Kapogiannis <gekapogi@yahoo.gr>, Kallinikou Dionysia <kallinikoudionysia@yahoo.gr>, Nikos Volanis <nikos.volanis@gmail.com>, Panagiotis Kranidiotis <kranidiotis@hilonsys.com>, Prodromos Tsiavos <p.tsiavos@lse.ac.uk>, sarantos <sarantos@ionio.gr>, Tavlaki Elena <etavlaki@aegean.gr>, Yannis Tsop <ogiannhs@gmail.com>, Zenon Mousmoulas <zmousm@admin.grnet.gr>, Zenon Mousmoulas <zmousm@grnet.gr>, Βασιλική Στρακαντούνα <vstrakan@lib.uoa.gr>, ΕΛENA ΣΠYPOΠOYΛOY <elena@eexi.gr>, ΜΑΡΙΝΟΣ ΠΑΠΑΔΟΠΟΥΛΟΣ <marinos@marinos.com.gr>, Φώτης Πανδής <f.pandis@infosoc.gr>
  • Cc: cc-gr@lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: [Cc-gr] fyi: Copyright extension is out of tune with reality...
  • Date: Sat, 17 Jan 2009 00:27:24 +0200

...

Politicians often do and say silly things when they come into contact with celebrities.

So it was last Thursday when a star-struck Andy Burnham, Britain's secretary of state for Culture, Media and Sport, showed up for a speech and photo-opportunity with the former lead singer of the Undertones, a punk-pop combo of the 1970s. In addition to the usual pleasantries about Britain's creative industries, Mr Burnham set out a novel argument about the law of copyright protecting musicians' work.

There was, he said, "a moral case" for performers – who often do their best recorded work in their 20s and 30s – to benefit from it throughout their lifetime. The government would therefore consider extending copyright for recordings to 70 years from the present 50.

As political speeches go, this is pretty silly. A moral case? You might just as well say sportspeople have a moral case to a pension at 30.

Copyright is an economic instrument, not a moral one, and if you consider the economic arguments – as I did two years ago at the request of Gordon Brown – you will find that they do not stack up. All the respectable research shows that copyright extension has high costs to the public and negligible benefits for the creative community.

Consumers find themselves paying more for old works or unable to access "orphan works" where copyright ownership is unclear. Small businesses that play recorded music such as hairdressing salons and local radio stations face a hidden extra "tax" in the form of higher music-licence fees. Do they really need this at this time?

... http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/ba280756-ca07-11dd-93e5-000077b07658.html?nclick_check=1






--
Πριν εκτυπώσετε αυτό το μήνυμα, σκεφθείτε το περιβάλλον! Ένα χαρτί λιγότερο! - http://karounos.gr/blog/


  • [Cc-gr] fyi: Copyright extension is out of tune with reality..., Theodoros G. Karounos, 01/16/2009

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page