cc-europe AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Cc-europe mailing list
List archive
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science
- From: Thomas Margoni <thomas.margoni AT glasgow.ac.uk>
- To: <diane AT creativecommons.org>, <CC-Europe AT lists.ibiblio.org>
- Subject: Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science
- Date: Thu, 10 Aug 2017 17:01:48 +0100
Hi again, So, what we are trying to say, which I believe is consistent with Diane's email is: If a non original database which is protected only by SGDR is licensed with CC BY 4.0, licensees must attribute authorship even if SGDR comes with no such a requirement (i.e. no moral rights). Under this point of view, using a CC BY could be seen as more restrictive not only of CC0, but of the law because the law does not require attribution for SGDR. This is true, however, only if you need a licence (Diane's point), because if you do not need a licence, e.g. you are outside EU and there is no SGDR, then the licence is not triggered and you don't have to apply attribution if you use the work. However, if you are in a country where SGDR exists (e.g. EU) then you can only use that database if you accept the licence and the licence requires you to attribute (even if there is no such a corresponding legal requirement). The point should be: use CC0 for data not CC BY. If this is not clear enough please let me know and we can update the wording in the next version.
best, thomas
On 10/08/17 14:13, Diane Peters wrote:
CAJjMn5qZpa+1vKrTCcxRbf8PXQfPZw8zz7Rpm9S-UwTZcgpT6w AT mail.gmail.com"> -- Dr. Thomas Margoni Senior Lecturer in Intellectual Property and Internet Law Director of the LLM in Intellectual Property and the Digital Economy School of Law - CREATe Centre University of Glasgow http://ssrn.com/author=1383303 |
-
[CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Thomas Margoni, 08/10/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Maarten Zeinstra, 08/10/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Diane Peters, 08/10/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Thomas Margoni, 08/10/2017
- Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science, Maarten Zeinstra, 08/17/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Thomas Margoni, 08/10/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Diane Peters, 08/10/2017
-
Re: [CC-Europe] ccuk fact sheet and FAQ on Open Science,
Maarten Zeinstra, 08/10/2017
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.