development of an education license or license option for Creative Commons

["Ms. Heather Ford" <hford AT stanford.edu>]

Thanks, Stephen - this is really useful advice.

At 04:33 AM 12/11/2003, you wrote:
Hiya,

I think that this is an interesting proposal with a lot of merit. However,
I do have a suggestion to make.

The proposal described below is what I would characterize as a
'centralized' proposal. By that, what I mean is that it suggests that 
the content and services would be stored on a single, centralized,
web site.

My alternative would be to, instead of developing a single website,
to develop and encourage the use of a set of tools that would
perform the same functions for many websites. To create, for 
example, tools that allow people to create their own version of
the CC-Edu resource base listed here.

Ok, so take the case studies, for example. The tool would be a template 
for creating case studies. Once the author has created the case study and 
uploaded it to their own site, it would be linked to other case studies 
via a directory in the tool site. Is this what you mean? 


This distributed network of CC-Edu sites would be linked 
through a process of harvesting and aggregation. This would
allow individual users to select only those materials that are
most relevant to their needs.

A distributed network is significantly more scalable than
a centralized node, and it spreads the cost of hosting and
administration around. It also allows more flexibility for
individual providers, and lets them manage and control 
their own materials.

Can David Wiley comment on this with regard to the Educommons project? It 
seems as though it is based on a similar premise i.e. not just looking at 
developing specific content for specific audiences, but rather looking at 
a more sustainable development of tools that enable others to develop any 
content for any audience. This makes a lot of sense.

H.


-- Stephen 

Heather Ford wrote:

Hi all, 

Back in Johannesburg after an epic journey involving 3 days stuck at JFK 
Airport due to snow storms. I have been awake since 2.30am - ah, the joys 
of travelling ;) 

I wanted to aggregate our discussions over the past 2 weeks and apply them 
to a specific theme: Creative Commons 101. This would be an online tool 
that enables educators to share resources and ideas about how to teach 
students about the concepts and philosophy of open content. Pretty much an 
extension of the discussions that we've been having about how to make it 
easier to actually make practical use of CC content - but starting on a 
small scale with a particular topic, rather than dealing with how to find 
open content throughout the web. 

I know that Lessig and Glenn Otis Brown have been teaching a Creative 
Commons course at Stanford this year - so it would be useful if one of 
them could provide input here - especially with regard to the mode of 
teaching i.e. were case studies used? where were these sourced from? what 
lessons were learned? did student assignments produce any new knowledge? 

I was thinking about CC South Africa and wondering how we could form a 
partnership with universities around the country that would make maximum 
use of students as volunteers. One of the major advantages of housing CC 
at a university is that one can leverage student support by teaching a 
course and perhaps using assignments as a way of generating new ideas and 
actions for CC in a particular country. There is also the opportunity to 
share case studies and ideas etc across geographical boundaries to give CC 
the global context that it requires in order to be truly successful. 

So what I propose is a website and accompanying mailing lists that have 
the following facilities: 

1. Users/curriculum developers sign up as authors and develop personal 
profiles detailing: country, institution, reasons for joining, personal 
interest, experience (subject/discipline), links to personal websites 
etc., rating according to number of times the author has a) downloaded b) 
uploaded material etc (lurker, weed, guru etc) 

- note: each entry would be linked to other individuals with the same 
entries eg if the author enters South Africa as her country of residence, 
then they could find all other authors from South Africa (Friendster 
model) 

2. Authors contribute case studies consisting of: legal reports, news 
stories/blog entries, images, cartoons, audio, video, multimedia licensed 
under open content (authors must upload these resources giving full 
license/author details as well as short descriptions/summaries of 
materials to enable extensive metadata with which to search) - case 
studies can be edited and updated by others when they re-use (wikis?) ALSO 
fact sheets with information about a particular country's Internet 
penetration (perhaps classified as 'high', medium, low so that authors can 
join collaborative groups according to access levels) 

 - note: is there a way that we can use the openoffice tool to produce, 
edit and update these docs? 

3. Teaching tips - authors share stories of: 'what works and doesn't work' 
in different learning environments (blog format?) 

4. Assignments - authors share examples of assignments that maximise the 
student providing useful, practical insight/action for the open content 
movement (perhaps choosing from a consistently updated 'to do' list) 

- note: there is also the opportunity to get students to partner with one 
another for a truly multidisciplinary approach to student assignments - 
students could partner up (within a class or even in other 
countries/regions) to produce material e.g. a graphic design student could 
partner with a law student to produce an animated video describing how the 
licenses work to an audience of musicians - you could even make this a 
random assignment where you choose: theme, audience and product to get the 
name of your assignment 

5. Search by: keyword, country, internet penetration group, resource 
(image, multimedia, fact sheet, case study etc), discipline (law, social 
science, music, journalism etc) 

4. Mailing list to alert authors to new resources, changes to their 
documents etc 

5. Mailing list to discuss progress of the project and ideas for 
collaboration (eg volunteer sharing) 

6. Opportunity for authors to host mailing lists according to new subjects 
eg Teaching Creative Commons in an Anthropology class, or Teaching 
Creative Commons to music students etc 

7. Links to cc education mailing list 

(Mailing lists would link to author IDs so that users could go directly to 
the website to find out more about authors of posts and put their ideas in 
a particular context - better than having to do your own ineffective 
investigations about authors when you join a list) 

The project would aim to build a *community* around the cc education 
license and to stimulate active engagement in the development of open 
content ideas on a global scale. 

Once a model has been developed, it could be applied to other subjects or 
multi-disciplinary learning areas. 
  
So, what do you all think? This probably can't all be done at once but it 
would be useful to hear which - if any - are the better ideas. 

Best, 

Heather. 

Heather Ford 
************************************************ 
www.hblog.org 
Reuters Stanford Digital Visions Program 
http://reuters.stanford.edu 
Cordura Hall, 220 Panama Street 
Stanford, CA 94305-4115, USA 
Cell: 650 380 4227 

_______________________________________________ 
cc-education mailing list 
cc-education AT lists.ibiblio.org 
http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/cc-education 

_______________________________________________
cc-education mailing list
cc-education AT lists.ibiblio.org
http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/cc-education
Heather Ford
************************************************
www.hblog.org 
Reuters Stanford Digital Visions Program
http://reuters.stanford.edu
Cordura Hall, 220 Panama Street
Stanford, CA 94305-4115, USA
Cell: 650 380 4227