Biblical Hebrew Forum

[George Athas <George.Athas AT moore.edu.au>]

OK Jim, you're not actually fostering any real discussion or interaction 
here. This has simply become yet another expression of speculative statements 
which no one can engage with, precisely because they are so speculative and 
have virtually no way of being tested. If you insist on your evidence coming 
from non-falsifiable assertions and repeating this ad nauseam, then please do 
so on a personal blog, not here at B-Hebrew.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, can I suggest before you next post 
here at B-Hebrew that you brush up on some basic familiarity with 
argumentation, evidence, logic, and the pitfalls of speculation. I'm not 
being pernicious with this comment. I'm actually quite serious. The reason I 
say this is that if you submitted any of your theories for examination at a 
tertiary institution, they would be failed not for being misguided 
necessarily, but rather for failing some basic rules in logical 
argumentation. None of us here at B-Hebrew I suspect have time to walk you 
through these here, other than simply to say that your statements are almost 
entirely speculative because they are assertions based on connections and 
evidence that cannot really be tested. So, Jim, for the sake of the list and 
for your own sake, please read, mark, and inwardly digest some material on 
the building blocks of logical arguments.


GEORGE ATHAS
Co-Moderator, B-Hebrew
(Sydney, Australia)