b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum
List archive
- From: yochanan bitan <ButhFam AT compuserve.com>
- To: "Bryan Rocine" <596547 AT ican.net>
- Cc: b-hebrew <b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
- Subject: weqatal in Jdg 3:23
- Date: Sun, 4 Oct 1998 07:04:14 -0400
bryan
just saw your weqatal note. i think your own instrincts are in the right
direction.
you need to add two more views:
5. veqatal = and he was in process of locking (the locks) . . .
(equivalent tense-aspect to yiqtol).
(this occurs elsewhere, 2 Sam 13.18)
here: multiple event, more than one lock on plural doors,
providing a pause as scene switches.
6. veqatal = veqatol (infinitive absolute, like phoenician. but we don't
really know enough about how this qatol functioned in narrative to
satisfyingly introduce it here.)
i prefer #5, though #1/2 and #6 are not impossible.
[another rule of thumb: always interpret the MT as one edition of the
text, even if secondary.]
[your own translation 'locker' overlaps with #5, though you may have overly
restricted the 'reading' of the TAM to a nominalization 'locker'.]
braxot
randall buth
-
Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23,
Paul Zellmer, 10/02/1998
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Bryan Rocine, 10/02/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Rolf Furuli, 10/02/1998
-
Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23,
Bryan Rocine, 10/02/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Rolf Furuli, 10/04/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Bryan Rocine, 10/02/1998
- weqatal in Jdg 3:23, yochanan bitan, 10/04/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Paul Zellmer, 10/05/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Rolf Furuli, 10/05/1998
- Re: weqatal in Jdg 3:23, Bryan Rocine, 10/06/1998
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.