[NAFEX] Fwd: [rarefruit] Discussion aims of the group

rob hamilton lostman_amiga at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 15 21:06:10 EDT 2007

Dear membership,

This is an interest comment. I have only been with NAFEX for about 6 years. Some some aspects or this post I agree and with and some I don't. I feel this is an excellent opportunity for our membership (at least the on-line ones) to chime in to let the board know what you want. 

These are my thoughts...

There is a alot of discussions on mainstream fruits in the on-line forum and in Pomona, though the varieties discussed are often are historical or rare and sometimes unorthodox uses of those fruits. That being said, I do see plenty of discussion of rare or under explored fruits, and kiwi or hardy kiwi is hardly and exotic fruit on our list. Ask Hector Black and Hall Love.  I personally would love to see more exploration of rarer fruit. I think (gut feeling here) members do, but may not actively report on them.
I also think that we do have a diversity of people on the whole chemical/organic spectrum. I am tired of seeing people place in just two extremes in this issue, and I do feel here people discuss and practice various methodologies and anyone would find a colleague in our membership that would see their interest represented. I do see the organic community growing, and that is an area I think we could find more members. 

I do NOT want this post to sound like I took offense at these comments. It is further from the truth. I thank Dr. Parmar posted this. My hope is that we can use it as a vehicle to ask ourselves if this is the group we want.

I think each fruit group out there has there own "flavor" of community. I am part  of Southern Fruit Fellowship, and the California Rare fruit group. There will always be overlap between them, though no group well satisfy everyone, I think we are a good general entry point for all people interested in temperate fruit.

Robert Hamilton

"Dr. Chiranjit Parmar" <parmarch at gmail.com> wrote: Here are some comments about NAFEXers from Rarefruit list.
 Dr. Chiranjit Parmar

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Michael Nave <jmichaelnave at yahoo.com >
Date: Apr 14, 2007 10:45 AM
Subject: Re: [rarefruit] Discussion aims of the group
To: rarefruit at yahoogroups.com

     I've given thought to the coolfruit/rarefruit group
issue and don't know what to do about it. Coolfruit is
to some extent displaced by the NAFEX list, although
unfortunately many of the folks on the NAFEX internet 
list are very mainstream apple/peach/plum growers who
love chemical agriculture and think kiwi fruit are
exotic fruits. Many aren't really fruit explorers at
all which was the original purpose of NAFEX. The NAFEX 
magazine is far more interesting than the NAFEX
internet group. The Dave's Garden groups also have
members that specialize in temperate fruit growing but
using the group is so clunky that I won't waste my 

I tend to think of rarefruit as a list for just that,
rare fruit, and the rarer the better. While there
really is nothing rare about mangos and jackfruit,
they are rare if you live in temperate areas. And 
truly edible lonicera is rare almost everywhere
outside of northern Europe, Canada and Japan.

I guess I just don't want to see rarefruit restricted
too much. If we say we can't discuss lonicera and cold 
hardy kiwi here, it just seems that the group loses
something. There will always be people who are not
interested in certain topics whether the topic is a
tropical, subtropical or temperate fruit, and they are 
under no obligation to follow those posts. Lord knows
I am usually bored stiff by rambutan, litchee and
langsat discussions. For me to try to grow them would
be way too much work and the payoff is just not worth 
the effort. On the other hand red fleshed jackfruit,
purple yams and purple fleshed durian are very
interesting to me whether I can grow them or not. My
point is just that no one is ever interested in all

But if we broaden the scope of rare fruit, then what
happens to coolfruit? That would have been a good
question in 2001 but right now coolfruit has so few
posts that I don't think the question matters much 

--- CannonConsult <b.cannon01 at verizon.net> wrote:

> Hi Mike,
> What you write is true. The question is do we need
> to advertise the 
> group more or include non warm climate edibles
> here? I tend to let the 
> group make such decisions even though I would love 
> to see the CoolFruit 
> group become more active. It has over 280 members
> with 76 bouncing so 
> that leaves about 200 that are still there to see
> posts.
> You have been in this group quite a while and in 
> CoolFruit since 1981. 
> Perhaps you would be willing to become a co-owner an
> promote the group 
> and see if it can be woken up? At this moment I
> simply do not have the 
> time to push it as much as I would like to. 
> If you, or any other list members, wish to contact
> me off list about 
> this feel free to do so at:  cannonconsult at myway.com
> Best of growing,
> Bob
> SW Florida USA
> Michael Nave wrote:
> > The problem Bob is that nothing ever happens on
> > coolfruit these days. It peaked in about 2001 when 
> > coincidentally Jan was a member and he I exchanged
> > emails about chestnuts and jujube and I believe I
> sent
> > him seeds from a Russian jujube cultivar I had at
> that
> > time. In 2001 coolfruit had about one message per 
> day.
> > Last year it had about one message every 3 days
> and
> > this year it is down to about one message every
> six
> > days with about a third of those messages coming 
> from
> > me and Phil Pieri.
> >
> > Mike
> >
> > .

Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around  

__._,_.___   Messages in this topic (0)  Reply (via web post) |  Start a new topic 
  Messages |  Files |  Photos |  Links |  Database |  Polls |  Calendar 
 Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required) 
Change settings via email:  Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional  
 Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use |  Unsubscribe 

   Recent Activity
  New Members
  New Photos

 Visit Your Group 
    Hydroponic gardening  
    Organic gardening  
    Home and garden decor  
    Gardening gloves  
    Gardening gloves 

   Cutest Kid
  Is your kid cute?
 Share and vote
 on Bix.com!

  Y! GeoCities
  Share Interests
 Connect with
 others on the web.

  Build a web site
 quickly & easily
 with Sitebuilder.



Best regards,

Very truly yours,

Dr. Chiranjit Parmar
186/3 Jail Road
Mandi  HP  175001 INDIA
 www.lesserknownindianplants.com  _______________________________________________
nafex mailing list 
nafex at lists.ibiblio.org

Reproduction of list messages or archives is not allowed.
This includes distribution on other email lists or reproduction on web sites.
Permission to reproduce is NEVER granted, so don't claim you have permission!

Posts from email addresses that are not subscribed are discarded.
No exceptions.  
To subscribe or unsubscribe, go to the bottom of this page (also can be used to change other email options):

File attachments are NOT stripped by this list.
Please do not send binary files.
Use plain text ONLY in emails!

NAFEX web site:   http://www.nafex.org/

Now Zone 8a!!  Atlanta, GA

Atlanta Fruits Club                                        www.groups.yahoo.com/atlanta_fruits
North American Fruit Explorers (NAFEX)                           www.NAFEX.org
Southern Fruit Fellowship (SFF)                                          www.NAFEX.org/SFF
Southeastern Palm and Exotic Plant Society (SPEPS)   
California Rare Fruit Growers
Ahhh...imagining that irresistible "new car" smell?
 Check outnew cars at Yahoo! Autos.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/private/nafex/attachments/20070415/75d4bafd/attachment.html 

More information about the nafex mailing list