[NAFEX] What do deer REALLY want?

kieran or donna redherring at tnaccess.com
Thu May 26 21:32:38 EDT 2005


> Does anybody have any experience using chemical deer repellents (e.g.
> brands Liquid Fence, Tree Guard, Deer-Away, Deer-Off, Plantskydd, Plant
> Pro-Tec sticks etc.)

Oh, I was beginning to feel a bit hopeful, till I read the response:

>rinse out your sprayer really well, since
the smell of dried blood attracts the flies.

So I suppose it won't keep coons away from corn!

>Many friends of mine swear by Downy dryer sheets pinned to the branches.

Yeah, I have heard of this one too, but would have to visit my trees only
from the upwind side.  Someone told me that we could keep ticks off us by
wearing those stinky things in a back pocket.  I said I'd rather risk Lyme
Disease.  Can't tell for sure yet if the guineas are making headway on the
tick problem, but as the one remaining hen is setting on 22 eggs, we may
find they make more impact next year.  Not sure what kind of effect they may
have on my tomato crop this year though.

>I also assume eventually the deer get used to
the scent

Nope, if they are like me, they will never get used to the smell.  Good
thing I don't know any important military secrets, because you could get
them out of me pretty easily by threatening me with Bounce.  And let's not
forget the awful rashes after someone accidentally put some Downy in my
washer at the laundromat.  Took 3 washings to get rid of it.

>It was a carrot-and-stick strategy: the fence was difficult to jump, and
the clover
was free for the taking.

Yes, I do think that this has something to do with success or failure of
deer repellents.  There are hundreds of acres around us with plenty for deer
to eat, from cornfields to woods to nice rolls of hay in the winter.  They
don't need to come to our relatively small garden where the dogs are going
to go after them.  I know they come near because sometimes I hear them snort
down the hill, and once in a while the dogs will go charging off through the
woods and I'll hear the sound of bounding deer.  One year one was coming to
the far end of the garden and eating the leaves off my beans.  I covered
them with netting and it quit.  Either it didn't find anything else I had
that attractive, or more likely the dogs started checking the area more
often in hopes of catching it.  (Hope springs eternal in a dog's heart)  My
husband reminds me that he strung 6 lb test monofilament around that area as
well.  We used to run into it a lot ourselves.
    But when the population of deer is fairly high, and the amount of really
yummy food is fairly low, I doubt much of anything would deter deer.  I had
goats for years, and they have a lot in common.  Here is a question though:
If the surrounding soil is fairly depleted in some minerals and you add them
to your orchard, could it be that your orchard really is more tasty and
nutritious than anything around?  Stephen's easy access clover vs
hard-to-reach orchard are what made me think of it.  I read about an
experimental field where one quarter had been limed.  Round bales were made
from the grass and left where they landed.  Cattle were wintered in the
field and allowed to eat as they chose.  For the next 13 years, the cattle
ate every bale in the area that had been limed before they touched any of
the other 3/4 of the bales.  After that, the effect of the single liming
seemed to wear off.  Maybe if you do something to make your fruit trees
taste more nutritious, maybe you need to do the same thing for some other
area.  Then minimal fencing or deer repellents might work.  Actually, maybe
all the deer need is a phosphate block, seeing as that's something that
you'd use on an orchard to encourage fruit production.  Nitrogen makes
plants grow fast and succulent, but might not improve the flavor all that
much... but I think artificial N fertilizers also tend to up the sodium
content of the ground, and presumably the plants?
What do ya'll think?    Donna




More information about the nafex mailing list