[Market-farming] ? about moon phase planting

Richard Robinson rrobinson at nasw.org
Wed Oct 30 10:17:18 EDT 2013


On 10/30/2013 at 10:01:05 AM, Roots Farm wrote:
> Hearing it both ways:    All transplanting -- including above ground crops --
> done as moon waning.
>  Transplanting  of above ground crops best when moon waxing.
>
>
> Actually, am hearing even more confusions than this.  Does anyone have a
> credible system for maximizing good results re planting, transplanting, other
> garden tasks according to moon that may be amenable to tropics as well as
> temperate zone?  Or even just a really clear set of principles (that have
> been tested) that could be adapted?  Biodynamic methodologies interesting &
> likely prime, but just feel too complex for time/mind available. 

Your email prompted me to do some poking around on the web. I could not find any scientifically robust evidence that moon planting does, or doesn't, make a difference. I think one really clear principle that argues against any influence is that the most powerful known force at work between the moon and any object on earth is gravity. The gravitational attraction between the moon and a single seed is so negligible as to be unmeasurable (I think it's much smaller than the attraction between you and the seed, but I don't have the calcs at hand to confirm that), and is dwarfed by other effects having nothing to do with the phase of the moon, such as air pressure, humidity, soil moisture and chemistry, electrostatic charge, seed orientation, etc. etc. etc. 

A believer is likely to counter that the key word in the above paragraph is "known." If one believes in forces unknown to physics, then it's a different conversation. But to my mind, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence--i.e., rigorously conducted, blinded tests giving results that can be reproduced by others--and I don't think that exists for moon phase planting.


  Richard Robinson
  www.nasw.org/users/rrobinson/
  Hopestill Farm
  www.hopestill.com




More information about the Market-farming mailing list