[b-hebrew] First 9 Hebrew Words [full English text]
Nir cohen - Prof. Mat.
nir at ccet.ufrn.br
Tue Dec 4 22:37:31 EST 2012
considering your #7, for akkadian UBIL, its declension and the initial U/WA see e.g. caplice-snell p 74-75:
according to them, the akkadian biconsonant root bil, $ib (carry, sit) appear in the imperative,
but otherwise the prefix wa/u then indicates action.
it seems that this is well reflected in the hebrew cognate irregular verb Y$B: imp. $EB but otherwise YA-$AB.
ubil/ubal is similarly reflected by BH HOBYL/HUBAL.
similarly, aramean BLW may be connected with akkadian balu: say, products SENT to the local governor.
or a caravan SENT to the distant ruling city.
so, at the bottom line, you insist, is it hebrew or not?
#7 seems quite akkadian to me.
i think the paper you have just sent us is very good, and has a clear message: one cannot
attach simple labels to complex processes. your question "is it hebrew" is just too simplistic.
On Tue, 4 Dec 2012 19:51:48 -0500 (EST), jimstinehart wrote
> 7. u-bi-li-mi; u-bi-il. “I sent as gifts to the king, my lord, xprisoners, 5,000…, and 318 porters/u-bi-li-mi for the caravans of the king….” Amarna Letter EA 287: 53-57. “Look, I am a friend of the king, and atribute-bearer/u-bi-il of the king, I am.” Amarna Letter EA 288: 11-12. “porters” ??? Cf. the Aramaic word BLW, meaning “tribute”,at Ezra 4: 13?? [Does that word inAmarna Letter EA 287 actually refer to the “taxpayers” of Jerusalem, who are“tribute-bearers” in the sense that they have funded the “tribute” forIR-Heba’s caravan that is being sent to Egypt? Or by contrast is the reference, asconventionally thought, to “[captive] porters” who are slaves being sent toEgypt as “tribute” as part of the caravan? Cf. also the Hebrew word BLH in the form BLTYat Genesis 18: 12, though the meaning does not seem to fit too well???]
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the b-hebrew