[b-hebrew] "Dan" in Ezekiel 27: 19
JimStinehart at aol.com
JimStinehart at aol.com
Thu Dec 27 17:06:32 EST 2007
Karl W. Randolph:
Ezekiel 27: 19 says that the island city-state of Sur/Tyre in southern
Lebanon traded with “Dan” (or “Vedan”) and with “Javan”.
1. The “Dan” or “Vedan” at Ezekiel 27: 19 is traditionally associated with
“Aden” in Arabia, I believe. But that is not necessarily correct. “Dan”/“
Vedan” is linked with “Javan” in the text, and “Javan” is viewed as being
Greece. To me, northern Canaan, or Lebanon, or Syria might be more logical
pairings with a reference to Greece for the trading partners of Sur/Tyre than
would be Arabia.
2. The questions of how ancient the name “Dan” might be, and where this “Dan
” might be located, may take us all the way back to the 14th century BCE, and
may involve some connection of “Dan” to Sur/Tyre.
3. You wrote: “Background to this verse [Ezekiel 27: 19]: this is part of a
list of trading countries with Tyre. Judah and Israel have already been
mentioned as providers mainly of agricultural goods, in verse 17.”
(a) In the Hebrew Bible (with the possible exception of Genesis), what Greek
and English speakers call “Tyre” is spelled either tsade-resh or
tsade-vav-resh. That is CR or CWR here. In ancient times, the tsade was probably
pronounced S or SS, vs. the modern pronunciation of TS, so the ancient sound may
have been SUR. If so, sin-vav-resh, which is found at Genesis 20: 1 (as
previously discussed on a different thread), could have been an alternate spelling for
this same locale. BDB sees one of the meanings of tsade-vav-resh as being “
rocky wall”, and sin-vav-resh means “wall”, so the meanings seem similar.
Importantly, this place is “Sur” in Arabic, and “Surru” in the Amarna Letters.
So I will refer to this island city-state in southern Lebanon as “Sur/Tyre”.
(In my view, the Greek mispronunciation “Tyre” is misleading.)
(b) Here is the text of Ezekiel 27: 17 that you reference:
“Judah, and the land of Israel, they were thy [Sur’s/Tyre’s] traffickers;
they traded for thy merchandise wheat of Minnith, and balsam, and honey, and
oil, and balm.”
That means that the Hebrews sold agricultural products to Sur/Tyre.
(c) Consider also I Kings 5: 25:
“And Solomon gave Hiram [of Sur/Tyre in trade] twenty thousand measures of
wheat for food to his household, and twenty measures of beaten oil”.
That likewise means that the Hebrews sold agricultural products to Sur/Tyre.
(d) The island city-state of Sur/Tyre was unique in the ancient world, in
that while it was rich, it had to import all its food. The one place where a
Hebrew might sell a bumper crop, at sky-high prices, was Sur/Tyre. For that
reason, Sur/Tyre was far more important to the early Hebrews than is usually
recognized. Ezekiel 27: 17 and I Kings 5: 25 are but the tip of the iceberg in
that regard, in my opinion.
4. In 14th century BCE Ugarit, located on the west coast of Syria, “Daner”
was a prominent name. “Dan” could be viewed as being a shortened form of the
truly ancient name “Daner”.
5. Both Sur/Tyre and Ugarit were rich trading states in the mid-14th century
BCE. There are plenty of connections between Sur/Tyre and Ugarit. Although
Ugarit lasted only about 200 years or so, Sur/Tyre remained unbowed and rich
until Alexander the Great built the causeway that destroyed Sur/Tyre’s previous
invulnerability to attack.
6. In short, there are plenty of ancient connections of the name “Dan” to
northern Canaan, Lebanon and Syria. The name seems redolent of that general
7. Some form of the name “Dan” was probably associated with the general
area of northern Canaan, Lebanon and Syria prior to the time that the Hebrew
tribe of Dan became associated with northern Canaan. The city originally called “
Laish” or "Lasha" or “Leshem” or “Lais” or “Lesem” or “Lus” or “Luz”,
which is located directly east of Sur/Tyre on the upper Jordan River, was later
called “Dan” by the Hebrews.
**************************************See AOL's top rated recipes
More information about the b-hebrew