[b-hebrew] pre-exilic(?) Hebrew a CV-beat language.
kwrandolph at gmail.com
Mon Aug 20 17:57:59 EDT 2007
On 8/20/07, Garth Grenache <garthgrenache at hotmail.com> wrote:
> Dear all,
> What Peter Bekins is saying mirrors the conclusions I've been reaching recently: i.e. that Semitic (and pre-exilic Hebrew) was made up of CV- segments, pronounced on a beat.
> Love from Garth.
Hold on to that for a second. Do you mean all of Biblical Hebrew, or
only the poetic sections?
I noticed that the poetic sections, for example Isaiah is mostly
written in poetic beat, reading the text pronouncing all (or almost
all) syllables as CV usually gives a definite beat.
But then I look at examples like Genesis 1–2:4, and that is prose;
other than a few verses, there's no beat at all. You can try using the
Tiberian tradition, and again no beat. If you say that some consonants
may close a syllable, while others not, maybe you could tease a beat
out of that chapter, but which consonants may close a syllable (have a
null vowel) and which require an expressed following vowel?
I am not arguing against your proposal, merely asking for more clarification.
Karl W. Randolph.
More information about the b-hebrew