[b-hebrew] metheg, stress
decaen at origin.chass.utoronto.ca
Mon Aug 6 09:28:28 EDT 2007
i would also suggest august is prime summer holiday season: i suspect a
lot of regulars are away.
* * *
metheg is usually called ga`ya by the specialists.
try the english translation of israel yeivin's book, introduction to the
tiberian masorah (1980), esp. ##311ff. on ga`ya.
if you surf the internet, look for a CV for geoffrey khan, who might 've
written on the topic. also look for programmes for the international
organization for masoretic studies: it might appear as in conference
* * *
i would say that it is definitely not stress, and definitely not about
open syllables. it is primarily musical, varying by the nature of the
syllable, the accent it is associated with, how many syllables before the
stress, etc. in the lingo, it is IMHO a text-to-tune interface phenomenon.
this seems esp. clear in the poetic books, with the poetic accent system.
i have been meditating on job 3. i draw your attention to a few examples.
(1) YFNW.^XA^ LIY^ 3:13, marking a furtive pathah: there are two major
classes of post-tonic syllables marked by so-called metheg-ultima, one of
which is the sequence pathah+guttural (i'd love to know what exactly is
going on here with the pharyngeals).
(2) Y:^HIY^ XO^$EK: 3:4, two unstressed syllables marked for the sake of
the trope: ordinarily, maqqef would appear in such "stress clashes"; but
the accent/trope has its own demands here. (just how would you stress the
(3) )OR:R"Y-YOW^M 3:8, the long syllable )O does bear a secondary stress,
in my opinion, but for reasons of the athnach-trope rules, a maqqef is
here: the reverse situation.
(4) HA^M:MAL:)IY^M 3:15, i would argue that HAM is a closed syllable; here
the demands of accent tarcha are at work. see further HA^M:XAK.IY^M 3:21.
these are generally associated with loss of gemination, contrast
HA&.:M"XIY^M 3:22 without metheg.
(5) W:^LO)-NFX:T.IY^ 3:26, shwa on we- is function of revia (notice here,
crucially without geresh, when virtual athnach).
Dr Vincent DeCaen
DeCaen and Associates Research and Communications
135 Bleecker Street, Suite 307
Toronto ON, M4X 1X2
vince at decaen.ca
Information provided is compiled from sources believed to be reliable, but
no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made by DeCaen and
Associates as to its accuracy, completeness or correctness.
More information about the b-hebrew